Brynn Nheiley and Sheila Jones are no longer working for the City.

By Pepper Parr

March 22nd, 2024

BURLINGTON, ON

 

Responding on behalf of Tim Commisso, City Manager – Further to your requests to Council members and Corporate Communications, I can confirm Brynn Nheiley and Sheila Jones are no longer working for the City.

Sheila Jones was an Executive Director with the city.

Brynn Nheiley Was an Executive Director with the city.

As you know, it’s our policy not to comment on personnel matters, but I would like to note that the City is grateful to Brynn and Sheila for their many important contributions over the years and we wish them the very best in their future endeavours.

These two woman were amongst the very best the city had.  Both will be picked up very quickly by some other municipality.

Now to find out more of the why.

At this point there is nothing on the city web site where decisions the Mayor has made under the Strong Mayor legislation would have to appear.

 

Return to the Front page

Brynn Nheiley announced as Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation & Mobility

By Staff

May 12, 2022

BURLINGTON, ON

 

The City of Burlington announced the hiring of Brynn Nheiley as the Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation & Mobility.

Nheiley has nearly seven years of public sector experience, including three years at the City of Burlington as the Manager of Development & Design in the Community Planning Department.

Brynn Nheiley

As the Manager of Development & Design, Nheiley led a number of initiatives that has led to improvements in development planning that support better outcomes for Council, residents and staff; these include:

Establishing a two-stage reporting strategy in order to provide Council with the opportunity to make a decision on an application within the legislated timeline, while also enabling the flexibility for staff to work with applicants to create the best planning outcome for development applications.

Bringing together staff from key departments to collaboratively build a development review process that gives applicants a single point of contact, and single application to satisfy multiple pre-approvals, from multiple departments, which are required before a building permit can be applied for.>

Bringing together a management team that included staff from building, planning, forestry, site engineering and Information Technology Services departments in order to launch an entirely digital review process for all forms of development applications. The result was that the City’s development review process was delayed by less than two months from the start of the Covid-19 pandemic.

Prior to working at the City of Burlington, Brynn worked for the City of Hamilton as a Senior Planner and as the Acting Director of Planning and Building Services for the Town of Antigonish in Nova Scotia.

Brynn has a Masters of Planning from Dalhousie University and a Bachelor of Architectural Science from Ryerson University.

 

 

 

Return to the Front page

Portside: 'They stopped working for the city in 2023 but earned over $100,000, from the city in 2024 - how did that happen?

Jim Portside

April 7th, 2025

BURLINGTON, ON

 

Even more on that Sunshine list.

Three other Sunshine List entries are curious. We’re discussing salaries paid to real people so I will not use names.

Two of the three people stopped working for the city in 2023, the other person had retired.

The two people who stopped working for the city in 2023 are on the 2024 Sunshine List. In other words, they stopped working for the city in 2023 but earned over $100,000, from the city in 2024.

The person who is now retired started working for the city in 2001 and has never appeared on the Sunshine List. In 2024 this person is on the Sunshine List earning a little under $115,000. We came up with three explanations:

  1. Maybe this person earned less than $100,000 in 2023, maybe they received a 14+% raise in 2024 and retired at the end of the year.
  2. Maybe this person was let go in 2023 and received severance in 2024.
  3. Maybe this person was let go in 2024 and received severance to push their 2024 salary over $100,000.
  4. Maybe the city can provide an explanation?

It al takes place at City Hall.

The City will take the position that the information is related to a specific individual and is treated as private.

No matter how it is explained – it smells

For the two people who stopped working for the city in 2023. One received about $105,000 in salary in 2024; the other about $111,000 in 2024.

What happens when you include Brynn Nheiley, Sheila Jones, and Tim Commisso? Our calculations, based on the limited information available to the public, show this gang of 6 cost the city approximately $868,674.98

Our calculations, based on the limited information available to the public, show this gang of 6 cost the city approximately $868,674.98.

How are taxpayers, the people who provide most of the money needed to pay staff, faring?

Not all that well it appears.

The record indicates that 3% of taxpayers have outstanding tax bills, the highest level in 5 years.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Return to the Front page

What did that Sunshine list tell us about some of the talent at city hall - that they are expensive

By Jim Portside

April 7th, 2025

BURLINGTON, ON

 

More on that Sunshine List.

The Sunshine List was first released in 1996; it shows Ontario public sector employees earning $100,000 or more. The $100,000 threshold has not changed since 1996. Using the Bank of Canada’s inflation calculator, $100,000 in 1996 is the equivalent of $185,017 in today’s dollars.

People who made over $200,000 in 2024.

Here’s a list of the top income earners for the city of Burlington, people who earned over $200,000 a year in 2024. The 2023 list contained 15 names. The 2024 list also contains 15 names, it’s great that the number of people stayed the same. Some of these people do a fantastic job for the city.

What’s most interesting about the above list is that three of the 200K club members no longer work for the city.

Tim Commisso’s LinkedIn profile indicates he left the city in April of 2024. Sheila Jones – March 2024. Brynn Nheiley – March 2024.

You can read more about Brynn and Sheila’s departures here:

What did these three people cost taxpayers?

The calculations are approximate, but about $600,000 in severance or, in the case of Tim Commisso, payment to the end of his contract went out the door in 2024 for these three people. Mayor Meed-Ward often talks about the city needing funding from other levels of government; $600,000 buys at least one MRI machine for Joseph Brant Hospital.

Here are some other interesting items from the Sunshine List.

The Sunshine List doesn’t tell us when someone started or left the city’s employ. With that in mind,I looked at all the people who were on both the 2023 and 2024 Sunshine Lists. The average salary increase for this group was 4.31%.

The number of people working for the city and making over $100,000 a year increased by 10.5% to 505. The 2022 list contained 393 names, and the 2023 list contained 457 names.

Of the roughly 1,112 full-time employees, 505 now earn over $100,000 per year.

The 2024 list includes 15 people with the job title “Transit Operator”, up from 9 last year. Keep in mind that this includes overtime.  There are 4 people with the job title “Mechanic” and 3 people with the title “Officer, Animal Control”, up from 1 last year.

The six elected councillors had an average income of $118,876.64, down slightly from an average of $119,802.70 in 2023. Councillors over the age of 71 earned less, only making $117,321.96 a year. Councillor Sharman has fought hard to have this corrected, and we’ll see a bump for the senior councillors, Sharman and Bentivegna, in 2025. The municipal employee pension plan, OMERS, has a rule that people over 71 have to start collecting their pension.

A total of 51 people saw their total earnings, salary plus overtime, increase by at least 10%. Only 23 of these people had changes in their job titles.

We’ll have to wait another year to see if Sheila, Tim or Brynn make it onto the 2025 Sunshine List.

Jim Portside is a retired business man who has lived in Burlington for several decades

 

 

 

 

Return to the Front page

2023 financial statements have been made public, better late than never.

By Eric Stern

August 25th, 2024

BURLINGTON, ON

 

Burlington’s 2023 financial statements have been made public, better late than never.

Here are some highlights.

Uncollected taxes indicate if people, and businesses, are struggling to pay their tax bills after the significant tax increases of 2022 and 2023.

All amounts are in thousands of dollars so the city is trying to collect $16,810,000 in past-due taxes. The uncollected amount increased, 2022 to 2023, by 37%.

The value of the city’s investments has increased 12.29%, over the 2022 number, to $321,214,000.

Obligatory reserve funds increased to $113,136,000, a 45% increase over 2022.

Reserve funds set aside: Left column 2023 – right column 2022

Reserve funds set aside by the council now total $145,306,000. This block of reserve funds has increased in value by 7.69%.

Long-term debt repayments over the next 5 years total $114,403,000.

The segmented expenses show that salaries and wages increased by 7.74% over 2022.

Sheila Jones, formerly an Executive Director with the City left with basically no notice. The circumstances of her departure were never very clear.

The percentage increase in the number of people working for the city continues to exceed the percentage increase in Burlington’s population. Unfortunately, severance costs are not stated in the financial report so it remains unclear what the senior-level departures of people like Brynn Nheiley and Sheila Jones cost taxpayers. Significantly above inflation salary increases also contribute to this change.

The full financial statement can be found on the city’s website by googling Burlington Ontario 2023 financial statements.

Ontario requires municipalities to use the Canadian public sector accounting standards or PSAS for short. This is the first financial statement, from Burlington, that follows the PSAS standards.

Eric Stern is a Burlington resident who is not an account.  His experience was in the tech world where he ran a private company quite successfully for a number of years and then retired.

Return to the Front page

How Mayor Meed Ward can stop the rumours in Burlington.

By Eric Stern

April 6th, 2024

BURLINGTON, ON

 

On March 30th Mayor Meed Ward wrote the following commentary piece in the Spectator:

“It is truly unfortunate to see the misinformation, speculation and rumour circulating in the community on these matters, and more discouraging to see some of those same rumours repeated in a column in The Spec on March 28.”

On March 28th, Spectator columnist Joan Little had asked a simple question:

“Why is all this happening at once? Because of the power a mayor has to hire and fire?”

Mayor Marianne Meed Ward: “It is truly unfortunate to see the misinformation, speculation and rumour circulating in the community on these matters…”

In the mayor’s commentary, she makes no attempt to answer Little’s question or to provide any information to stop the speculation and rumours surrounding multiple senior leadership departures at city hall. The mayor goes on to state “our residents deserve accurate and fact-based news and opinion coverage”.

Given that the City of Burlington employs people with serious communication skills it’s really surprising that, quoting the mayor, “misinformation, speculation and rumour” cannot simply be explained by someone, anyone, from the city providing “accurate and fact-based” information.

If Brynn Nheiley and Sheila Jones were fired, the severance and legal costs will be in the six-figure range for each one of them. Do taxpayers have a right to know how their money is being spent?

As a taxpayer, I have to wonder if the communications department is nothing but a taxpayer-funded PR organization for the mayor.

Something unusual is happening in politics and there are echoes in history. Napolean owned two military newspapers, allowing him to directly communicate with the military and public. After coming to power, he closed down 60 of the 73 newspapers in Paris.

Germany, in 1923, had 467 radio listeners. By 1932, there were over four million paying radio subscribers in Germany. Hitler was able to use this new technology to directly communicate with the public.

With changes in technology come political shifts.

We are at the beginning of the social media age. A new technology that allows our leaders to directly communicate with the public. Both Justin Trudeau and Pierre Poilievre make extensive use of social media.

Eric Stern: “I am suggesting that without the balance of editors and reporters, the direct messages from our politicians and their PR professionals have the potential to be misleading.”

I’m not suggesting either will become dictators. I am suggesting that without the balance of editors and reporters, the direct messages from our politicians and their PR professionals have the potential to be misleading. Should we be looking at these direct messages from our politicians with a healthy dose of skepticism? Should we check the information with other sources, including newspapers and TV news and form our own opinions?

Newspapers were new in the late 1700s, radio was new in the 1930s. Do we place more trust in what we read or hear from a new technology source simply because it’s new?

Quoting the University of Chicago Press, “in the case of Donald Trump, Twitter seems to have been one of the key enablers for his meteoric rise to power, rather than the means to challenge or take away that power”.

Kellyanne Conway,  Advisor to President Trump, coined the term “alternative facts”.

As  a taxpayer, I expect facts.

Mayor Meed Ward, or her communications team, posts directly to LinkedIn, FaceBook, Instagram, X (Twitter), Threads and on https://mariannemeedward.ca/

The startling lack of information about the recent departures from city hall is a form of misinformation. With all of this ability to directly communicate with city staff and the public Mayor Meed Ward should be using information to counter misinformation instead of accusing Joan Little of spreading rumours.

Are strong-mayor powers coupled with a PR machine what the residents of Burlington want? Please help send a message to Mayor Meed Ward by signing Blair Smith’s “Restoration of Democracy at Burlington City Council” petition on change.org   Click HERE

 

 

 

Return to the Front page

City manager takes exception to our suggesting it was the Mayor who fired two senior staff members

By Pepper Parr

April 3rd, 2024

BURLINGTON, ON

 

We received the following from the City Communications people earlier today:

“With respect to recent changes in City of Burlington leadership roles, at no time have I spoken directly to the Burlington Gazette or any other publication asserting or implying that strong mayor powers have been used for this purpose. They have not.”

The Gazette never said that we spoke to Tim Commisso on this matter.

Here is what we published, the words were sent to us by the Communications people

 “Responding on behalf of Tim Commisso, City Manager – Further to your requests to Council members and Corporate Communications, I can confirm Brynn Nheiley and Sheila Jones are no longer working for the City.

“As you know, it’s our policy not to comment on personnel matters, but I would like to note that the City is grateful to Brynn and Sheila for their many important contributions over the years and we wish them the very best in their future endeavours.”

Commisso appears to be concerned with what we published in the following article – Link is HERE

Commisso seems to be saying that the removal of two senior staff members was not the result of the Mayor using her Strong Mayor powers.  If the Mayor didn’t fire the two women then the City Manager did.

The only thing we do know is that two of the Executive Director level people are no longer with the city.  Sooner or later the full story will come out – it always does.

What a heck of a way for Tim Commisso to end a career.

 

Return to the Front page

Mayor uses forked tongue to explain what she doesn't want to talk about - and them dumps on the messengers because they open the kimona

By Pepper Parr

April 1st, 2024

BURLINGTON, ON

 

Well then – who did fire two of the top level city hall staff?

There are only two people who can fire a city employee:  The City Manager and the Mayor IF shes uses her Strong Mayor Powers.

IF the Mayor fires a staff member using her Strong Mayor powers she is required to post a notice on the city web site saying what she did and why she did it.

Now here is where it gets tricky.

Mayors says: “misinformation, speculation, rumour and fear mongering out in the community.”

The Mayor appears to have taken the position that she cannot write about the people who were fired because that would identify who they are and the rules the Mayor uses is that Burlington doesn’t name people publicly when there is a human resources matter.

The Mayor probably did not do the actual hiring herself: she would have directed the Executive Director of Human Resources to do the dirty – and, because that Executive is in place as an “interim” Executive Director, there was no way she was going to tell the Mayor it was not a task she was prepared to carry out.

We know the City Manager didn’t do the firing.  He told us via a message from the City’s Communications department on March 22nd.

City Manager Tim Commisso: not what he thought was going to happen when the Mayor chose him as City Manager after firing former City Manager James Ridge.

Here is what we were sent:

“Responding on behalf of Tim Commisso, City Manager – Further to your requests to Council members and Corporate Communications, I can confirm Brynn Nheiley and Sheila Jones are no longer working for the City.

“As you know, it’s our policy not to comment on personnel matters, but I would like to note that the City is grateful to Brynn and Sheila for their many important contributions over the years and we wish them the very best in their future endeavours.”

Mayor Meed Ward is telling anyone who will listen that there is “misinformation, speculation, rumour and fear mongering out in the community.”

The misinformation is coming out of the mouth of the Mayor; speculation and rumour are the result of the elected leadership failing to be accountable and transparent.

The fear that has infected city hall is the result of a Mayor that hides behind procedures.  Can you imagine the conversations that took place around the dinner tables of every single city employee during the Easter holiday?   How many have decided that it is perhaps time to move on and fined a greener pasture?

There are those that know the full story – but they aren’t ready to speak – they do not want to incur the wrath of a Mayor who has let the power she has to go to her head.

Power does reveal – doesn’t it?

Now to find out more of the why.

Related News story

At best Mayor’s response

Salt with Pepper is the musings, reflections and opinions of the publisher of the Burlington Gazette, an online newspaper that was formed in 2010 and is a member of the National Newsmedia Council.

 

 

Return to the Front page

The significant salary increases during 2023 are not the only problem facing the city - the revolt on the part of a majority of Council members is very serious

By Staff

March 30th, 2024

BURLINGTON, ON

 

The province of Ontario released the 2023 Sunshine list; the document that sets all those who earned more than $100,000 in the year 2023.

Here is a list of the top income earners for the city of Burlington, people earning over $200,000 a year.

The names in red are people who have retired or were let go.

When there are discussions related to staff salaries current City Manager Tim Commisso has explained that the city has to compete with other municipalities to get the talent it needs to be able t0 run a city that is expected to go through rapid population growth requiring large increases in housing.  Because Burlington has very little in the way of land within the urban boundary that can be purchased by developers what land there is available gets used for high rise towers.

The planning expertise for high rise housing requires talent that Burlington just didn’t have.  Add to that the changes made at the provincial level and you have a planning department that is struggling to stay on top of things.

Finally – there are the number of development application appeals that are at the Ontario Land Tribunal.  Preparing for those requires staff time and the need for a beefed up legal department.  It is far from a pretty picture.

Are other municipalities of comparable size going through the same experience?   We do know that the Mayor of Guelph chose not to take on the Strong Mayor Powers and that they were given a decent chunk of money for meeting their development targets.

Which leads to the question: Is the Burlington situation unique ?

What is clear is that the city has experienced some significant retirements – they knew that was coming.  The recent decision to let some very senior staff  go hasn’t helped.  The Mayor refuses to take responsibility for the decision citing information about people that is personal – yet the city manager was able to confirm that people the Gazette named has been let go.  Looks and sounds like forked tongues to me

The decision on the part of the current Mayor to double down on the Strong Mayors powers hasn’t helped either.  Add to that a Council that has yet to figure out a way to bring the Mayor to heal.

And finally – tax payers who have to pick up the cost of everything.  Expect the tax payer blow back during the last budget presentation to be repeated next budget.

While Council may not have figured out how to put a leash on the Mayor – citizens know exactly what to do.  Come the 2026 municipal election look for a blood bath.

Name Title 2022 2023 Increase %
Commisso, Tim City Manager  $   275,377.06  $   301,993.94 9.67
Ford, Joan Executive Director and Chief Financial Officer  $   242,396.60  $   263,169.11 8.57
Boyd, Laura Executive Director, Human Resources  $   211,310.92  $   256,119.08 21.20
Magi, Allan Executive Director, Environment, Infrastructure and Community Services  $   237,624.68  $   254,034.58 6.91
Shea Nicol, Nancy Executive Director, Legal Services and Corporate Council  $   242,464.89  $   253,409.31 4.51
Jones, Sheila Executive Director, Strategy Risk and Accountability  $   217,058.93  $   226,593.50 4.39
Nheiley, Brynn Executive Director, Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility  $   167,855.71  $   215,825.95 28.58
Macdonald, Chad Executive Director, Digital Service and Chief Information Officer  $   192,306.17  $   214,654.08 11.62
Scalera, Enrico Director, Roads Parks and Forestry  $   200,629.64  $   207,649.46 3.50
Anastasopoulos, Nick Director, Building Services and Chief Building Official #N/A  $   204,018.55 #N/A
Kummer, Craig Director, Transportation Services  $   180,785.86  $   204,018.42 12.85
Hamilton, Scott Director, Engineering Services  $   199,957.57  $   203,787.64 1.92
Ako-Adjei, Kwab Director, Corporate Communications and Engagement  $   183,423.83  $   203,370.23 10.87
Hurley, Blake Executive Director, Legal Services and Corporate Council  $   186,761.34  $   202,755.29 8.56
Meed Ward, Marianne Mayor  $   191,619.82  $   202,712.11 5.79

 

This is a list of everyone who received an increase of 10% or more. The list includes members of the fire department where overtime is being used to manage a staffing shortage.

Name Title 2022 2023 Increase %
Pawlik, John Deputy Fire Chief $107,660.18 $178,356.34 65.67
Cote, Emilie Director, Recreation, Community and Culture $127,990.25 $175,804.23 37.36
Remedios, Shirley Database Administrator $100,782.49 $137,108.19 36.04
Begbie, Alison Application Analyst $102,272.67 $134,975.90 31.98
Schustyk, Kevin Senior Traffic Signal Technician $103,479.41 $136,357.78 31.77
Nheiley, Brynn Executive Director, Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility $167,855.71 $215,825.95 28.58
Bell, Alan Architect, Digital Platform $106,938.75 $136,989.95 28.10
Tellier, Jamie Director, Community Planning $142,899.43 $180,291.55 26.17
Robinson, David Building Inspector $102,171.96 $126,663.32 23.97
Kumar, Anil Engineer, Building $120,126.63 $148,752.62 23.83
Weaver, Judy Architect, Digital Platform $111,697.74 $138,194.81 23.72
Kerr, Amanda Recreation Planner $103,194.02 $127,286.39 23.35
Bethlehem, Gerald Building Inspector $100,414.34 $123,658.76 23.15
Savrnoch, Gerald Building Inspector $100,545.64 $123,653.19 22.98
Malik, Umar Stormwater Engineer, Development $115,485.79 $141,089.04 22.17
Mahrous, Ebtessam Architect, Building $103,014.34 $125,849.61 22.17
Naismith, Andrea Consultant, Organizational Development $101,103.42 $123,295.77 21.95
Obal, Leigh-Ann Business Partner, Human Resources $110,944.95 $134,901.16 21.59
Boyd, Laura Executive Director, Human Resources $211,310.92 $256,119.08 21.20
Mchugh, Tina Manager, Data Analytics and Visualization $116,705.43 $141,019.05 20.83
Gagliano, Michael Architect, Digital Platform $107,585.83 $129,807.30 20.65
Mark, Kristen Application Analyst $129,210.15 $155,134.14 20.06
Rabeau, Marion Manager, Design and Construction – Parks $126,372.16 $151,688.54 20.03
Farbotko, Michael Architect, Digital Platform $113,640.45 $136,135.61 19.80
Garcha, Kulbir Manager, Information Technology Systems $136,513.08 $163,532.43 19.79
Robichaud, Lynn Manager, Environmental Sustainability $118,676.33 $141,670.27 19.38
Kennedy, Trudy Manager, Building Inspections and Deputy Chief Building Official $131,370.09 $156,128.34 18.85
Renner, Kirsten Supervisor, Payroll Services $100,595.14 $119,322.73 18.62
King, Chris Manager, Transportation Operations $104,303.14 $123,701.59 18.60
Schut, Paul Data Modeler $104,471.20 $123,677.97 18.38
Maas, Andrew Manager, Asset Planning $131,568.75 $155,165.03 17.93
Woods, Donna Business Partner, Human Resources $114,109.63 $134,295.75 17.69
Beishuizen, Roy Firefighter $103,659.33 $121,913.73 17.61
Yaromich, Janine Manager, Design and Construction – Roadways $132,755.44 $156,084.05 17.57
Plas, Kyle Manager, Development and Design $138,949.20 $163,114.45 17.39
Swioklo, Paul Manager, Corporate Fleet $102,383.70 $119,889.34 17.10
Maxwell, Sandra Manager, Festival and Events $102,780.96 $120,246.78 16.99
Filice, Suzanne Senior Business Partner, Labour Relations $114,658.16 $134,124.36 16.98
Enns, Alison Manager, Policy and Community Initiatives $133,664.96 $156,184.64 16.85
Clark, Cary Manager, Development and Stormwater Engineering $142,428.20 $166,384.24 16.82
Wing, Paul Firefighter $102,973.19 $120,060.90 16.59
Baldelli, Catherine Director, Transit $149,493.96 $174,144.74 16.49
Spence, Jennifer Manager, Recreation, Community and Culture Community Development $106,365.67 $123,815.43 16.41
Evfremidis, Susan Manager, Human Resource Services $129,514.06 $150,569.66 16.26
Dwyer, Michelle Manager, Engagement and Volunteers $111,362.63 $129,277.88 16.09
Holloway, Corry Fire Prevention Inspector $112,486.52 $130,088.27 15.65
Temoche, Peter Firefighter $138,352.86 $159,879.31 15.56
Higman, William Senior Plans Examiner $102,956.62 $118,966.26 15.55
Foster, Chris Public Safety Telecommunicator $118,437.14 $136,831.29 15.53
Puletto, Jenna Manager, Planning Implementation $113,503.62 $130,919.40 15.34
D’Angelo, Amanda Supervisor, Planning Services and Committee of Adjustment $105,859.82 $121,741.72 15.00
Jurczyk, Maciej City Auditor $155,481.78 $178,554.83 14.84
Armstrong, Samantha Captain $130,827.54 $149,751.06 14.46
Moore, Michelle Supervisor, Financial Reporting $137,636.23 $157,542.82 14.46
Cowman, Peter Supervisor, Field Services $106,365.09 $121,535.96 14.26
Collins, Scott Captain $143,432.56 $163,107.67 13.72
Vanderlelie, Daniel Platoon Chief $155,071.80 $176,127.68 13.58
Weake, Brad Manager, Tyandaga Golf Club $112,472.06 $127,470.65 13.34
Yuill, Melissa Analyst, Total Compensation $113,303.82 $128,401.90 13.33
Tiamiyu, Adedunmola Business Analyst $102,701.57 $116,175.89 13.12
Kummer, Craig Director, Transportation Services $180,785.86 $204,018.42 12.85
Davren, Kerry Manager, By-Law Enforcement $130,493.51 $147,230.57 12.83
O’Reilly, Sandra Controller and Manager, Financial Services $151,874.12 $171,229.94 12.74
Peterson, Richard Building Inspector $111,344.99 $125,441.38 12.66
Turner, Brett Firefighter $123,677.97 $139,102.66 12.47
Jivan, Lori Supervisor, Budgets and Policies $128,894.13 $144,900.01 12.42
Boyd, Brett Supervisor, Cemetery Operations $105,502.43 $118,556.60 12.37
Ullah, Sef Manager, Strategy and Portfolio Management $129,552.45 $145,440.78 12.26
Selkirk, Colleen Specialist, Procurement $100,445.76 $112,246.24 11.75
Macdonald, Chad Executive Director, Digital Service and Chief Information Officer $192,306.17 $214,654.08 11.62
Bird, Marc-Andrew Manager, Recreation, Community and Culture Customer Experience and Marketing $105,462.82 $117,653.54 11.56
Pavlou, Kathy Senior Plans Examiner $102,836.60 $114,688.02 11.52
Medeiros, Joshua Project Manager, Site Engineering $102,516.79 $114,313.57 11.51
Krizan, Steve Senior Plans Examiner $101,556.55 $113,176.19 11.44
Mcisaac, Jeffrey Supervisor, Site Engineering $107,325.81 $119,578.80 11.42
Trella, Rich Manager, Recreation, Community and Culture Facility Operations $108,958.14 $121,381.15 11.40
Thorburn, Philip Deputy Fire Chief $163,407.25 $181,717.60 11.21
Akinloye, Florence Supervisor, Accounting Services $113,647.29 $126,177.99 11.03
Rukundo, Maxine Business Analyst $107,601.08 $119,361.14 10.93
Pedlar, Tom Supervisor, Energy and Emissions $106,034.59 $117,608.51 10.92
Duncan, Brian Supervisor, Roads, Parks and Forestry Technical Services $109,713.22 $121,680.93 10.91
Hagley, Robert Supervisor, Customer Experience $101,438.26 $112,495.86 10.90
Martin, Christopher Incident Safety Officer $148,072.93 $164,212.84 10.90
Ako-Adjei, Kwab Director, Corporate Communications and Engagement $183,423.83 $203,370.23 10.87
Kewell, John Senior Plans Examiner $109,928.18 $121,862.39 10.86
Rodgers, Mark Firefighter $114,323.26 $126,445.98 10.60
Sidhu, Kirpal Transit Operator $102,497.59 $113,362.26 10.60
Ellis, Rebecca Supervisor, Landscape Architecture $100,431.29 $111,049.12 10.57
Cook, Kelly Senior Planner, Policy $101,173.99 $111,825.25 10.53
Romlewski, Samantha Senior Planner, Community Initiatives $101,174.03 $111,825.22 10.53
Tuomi, Alyshia Supervisor, Asset Management $106,972.07 $118,219.95 10.51
Girgis, Hany Transit Operator $121,617.68 $134,151.55 10.31

 

 

Return to the Front page

Sunshine list: number of people making over $100,000 increased by 16%. - from 393 names to 457

By James Portside

March 28th, 2024

BURLINGTON, ON

 

The province of Ontario released the 2023 Sunshine list; the document that sets all those who earned more than $100,000 in the year 2023.

In 2023 Burlington’s operating budget was $314.3 million dollars and the capital budget was $72.6 million dollars.  Salaries come out of the Operating budget

The number of people working for the city and making over $100,000 per year increased by 16%. The 2022 list contained 393 names, the 2023 list contains 457 names.

Of the roughly 850 full time employees 458 people now earn over $100,000 per year. I’m wondering what the politically correct version of “too many chiefs and not enough Indians” is.

The 2023 list includes nine people with the job title “Transit Operator”, four people with the job title “Mechanic” and one person with the title “Officer, Animal Control”.

Of the people we elect to manage our tax dollars the one person with the job title “Mayor” earned $202,712.10 after a 5.79% raise and the six people with the job title “Councillor” each had an average income of $119,802.70 after a 6.28% increase.

A total of 84 people, outside of the fire department, received raises of more than 10%. Only 16 of these people had changes in their job titles.

Our city manager, who has resigned, received a 9.67% increase.

In first place is Emilie Cote as our “Director, Recreation, Community and Culture”. Emilie received a 37.34% salary increase in 2023.

In second place is Kevin Schustyk. Kevin is our “Senior Traffic Signal Technician” and received a 31.77% increase. Someone should tell Kevin that the traffic lights have yet to be  synchronized.

Rounding out the trifecta is Brynn Nheiley with a 28.58% increase bringing Brynn’s salary to $215,826.  (More than the Mayor) As reported in the Burlington Gazette, Brynn recently left the city and, assuming there is a severance package, the package will be based on the $215,826 salary. Brynn left the City of Hamilton and started working for Burlington in March of 2019. Brynn first appears on the sunshine list in 2020 meaning her salary moved from less than $100,000 in 2019 to $215,826 in 2023.

Meanwhile the number of taxpayers unable to pay their property taxes increase to 2.9% in 2023. The highest level in the past six years.

Obviously, all is well at city hall. After pushing through a 15.5% increase to property tax revenue in 2023, with almost no population growth staff have been richly rewarded.  Our mayor likes to call the 15.5% increase a 7.5% impact on our total tax bill but the reality is the city receives 15.5% more revenue from taxpayers in 2023 and, based on the sunshine list, they know how to spend the money.

Jim has lived in Burlington for much of his life and has watched the city change and grow over the years. With over 1,000 people working for the city there is a lot going on. As a now retired, successful business owner, Jim is interested in exploring and sharing some of what our local government is working on. You can reach Jim by emailing Jim.Portside@gmail.com

 

 

 

 

 

 

Return to the Front page

There is a dangerous information vacuum in the city - members of Council have a responsibility to communicate

By Pepper Parr

March 24th, 2024

BURLINGTON, ON

 

One of the tasks Brynn Nheiley had was to talk up all the reasons for working in Burlington.

At one point she was saying:

Brynn Nheiley

As you look through our current job openings, remember: the grass is greener at the City of Burlington. With approximately 890 full-time and 600 part-time employees, we focus on teamwork, collaboration and investing in our co-workers. It’s no wonder our employee turnover rate is less than 7 per cent (that’s good). The City of Burlington is an award winning city, filled with award winning staff. In fact, we put the “greater” in the GTA.

Brynn at one point believed every word she said – but she is no longer with the city; however, the 890 full time workers and the 600 part time workers are in place and they are talking to each other.

There is fear and apprehension among the city employees.

There is a vacuum with no on speaking on behalf of the city administration or city Council.

Mayor Meed Ward on the porch of her house preparing to broadcast to the citizens of the city during the lock down period of the pandemic.

During the pandemic the Mayor was everywhere; speaking from the porch of her house; in front of the hospital using a megaphone to tell the hospital workers that the city appreciated to work they were doing.

The Mayor organized caravans that drove through the city – she did whatever could and thought was needed to assure a worried public.

What we have now is an uninformed public getting whatever individual response Councillors are putting out.  We are not aware of any special editions of newsletters being issued by individual Council members.

We are not seeing a lot of chatter on the X platform.

If there is no voice from the leadership – people create their own voice – which is often frenetic.

All of this does not bode well for the city.  The chatter amongst those who work in the municipal sector is wicked.  These people work together closely – they collaborate their responses to the provincial and federal government.

One can only imagine the chaos at Ontario Big City Mayors, (OBCM) , of which Meed Ward is the current chair.

Ontario Big City Mayors family portrait – worth a thousand words

Holding a position like that requires the respect of your peers

Mayor Meed Ward’s reputation is being shredded by her council members; the people she works with at the Ministry of Housing must be having quite a chuckle at Burlington’s expense.

All this is happening within a vacuum created by city council and the administration.

The Gazette has asked each member of council to show the leadership expected of them when they were elected.

Return to the Front page

With $21 million in the bank the city explains what they will do with those dollars

By Staff

January 15th, 2024

BURLINGTON, ON

 

City responds to the $21 million the Government of Canada provided to encourage more affordable homes for Burlington, built faster.

Local and federal politicians take part in $21 million funding announcement.

Representing the city at the announcement event were: the Honourable Minister Karina Gould, MP for Oakville North – Burlington Pam Damoff, Burlington Mayor Marianne Meed Ward and Deputy Mayor of Housing, Burlington Ward 4 Councillor Shawna Stolte.

The funding is through the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC)’s Housing Accelerator Fund (HAF). HAF is an application-based program that provides funding directly to municipalities across the country to incentivize and support initiatives that will accelerate the supply of housing.

Action Plan for this investment in Burlington

These funds will support the implementation of some of the key actions in the City’s Housing Strategy, including expanding housing opportunities for Burlington residents by cutting red tape and implementing updated zoning.

As Burlington continues to grow, this significant investment will support the development of complete, low-carbon, and climate-resilient communities that are affordable, inclusive, equitable and diverse.

The City’s HAF Action Plan includes seven initiatives:

      1. Streamlining planning and building approval process.
      2. Implementing Major Transit Station Areas and Community Planning Permit System.
      3. Support and encourage the creation of additional residential units and consider opportunities to increase as of right permissions. Burlington is proposing four units as of right and a no parking minimum pilot within a specific geographic area.
      4. Identify opportunities to incentivize the creation of rental and non-market housing.
      5. Build community and partner capacity by creating a Housing Connections Centre.
      6. Public lands and partnerships.

One of the City’s proposed projects focuses around Major Transit Station Areas (MTSAs) and the development of a new tool, the Community Planning Permit System (CPPS). This will allow for quicker approvals on high-density developments without the need for re-zoning.

Housing Connections Centre

Another key initiative to support this Action Plan is the Housing Connections Centre. This centre will provide residents and developers resources like:

      • standard unit designs
      • ways to connect with partners,
      • access to incentives, and
      • information about
        • the benefits of diverse neighbourhoods and
        • how creating new housing can provide options for all Burlington residents.
  • The Housing Accelerator Fund helps cut red tape and fast track at least 100,000 new homes for people in towns, cities, and Indigenous communities across the country. It asks for innovative action plans from local governments, and once approved, provides upfront funding to ensure the timely building of new homes, as well as additional funds upon delivering results. Every agreement under the Housing Accelerator Fund will require municipalities to end exclusionary zoning and encourage apartment building around public transit in order to help seniors, students, and families. Local governments are encouraged to think big and be bold in their approaches, which could include accelerating project timelines, allowing increased housing density, and encouraging affordable housing units.
  • Burlington’s Housing Strategy was approved by Council in June 2022. This strategy creates a road map and acts as a guiding document for housing needs in the City of Burlington. It will help the City to work towards meeting the housing needs of the community and move us closer to reaching our Vision for housing in Burlington.
  • In October, 2023, Burlington City Council unanimously approved a motion to declare its intention to allow four residential units per lot. The motion builds on the City’s recent update to the Additional Residential Unit policies of the Official Plan and Zoning Bylaw to permit up to three residential units per urban residential lot which was approved by Council in September 2023. The motion also supported the City’s application to the Housing Accelerator Fund.

 

Burlington Mayor Marianne Meed Ward:  “This is a huge investment in building more homes, and especially more affordable homes, for our growing city. We can only do this with partnerships with all levels of government and the building industry. Together, we’re creating the Burlington of the future – a thriving community where everyone has access to a home they can afford. The funding will help us begin implementing some of the key actions identified in our City’s Housing Strategy. This is key to making sure we remain one of the most livable cities in Canada.”

Burlington Deputy Mayor of Housing, Ward 4 Councillor Shawna Stolte.

Burlington Deputy Mayor of Housing, Ward 4 Councillor Shawna Stolte: “The Housing Accelerator Fund is a tremendous opportunity for the City to begin to implement key actions identified in the City’s Housing Strategy. This funding is a testament to the contributions from the community and development partners who worked together to create a robust Housing Strategy to work toward our vision for housing: “Everyone is welcome in Burlington”. This program will drive systemic change and create the conditions needed to increase housing supply and affordability over both the short and long term.”

Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility, Brynn Nheiley.

Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility, Brynn Nheiley: “The Housing Accelerator Fund will allow us to focus on further streamlining our planning and building permit approvals process; implement the MTSA program; update our Zoning Bylaw and consider incentives for certain types of development. Under this funding, the City’s Action Plan includes a mix of initiatives that will result in some immediate increases in housing supply. Other projects will support improvements to the broader housing system and will take us into the future of housing in Burlington.”

Return to the Front page

There are some strong rowers in the boat called Burlington, but no one with a strong hand on the tiller

By Pepper Parr

January 5th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

OPINION

City Manager Tim Commisso, originally the Mayor’s choice as City Manager; he decided not to renew his contract.

The City Manager has announced he will not be renewing his contract.

The head of Human Resources and the City Solicitor have both retired.

The City Treasurer has announced that the budget put in place recently is the last one she will do.

The City Clerk and the Director of Communications are no longer with us.

Council is understood to be interviewing or reviewing resumes as they search for a new City Manager.

All this certainly doesn’t reek of confidence.

There are some top notch people in place on the administrative side: Shelia Jones, Executive Director and Chad McDonald who heads up the technical and IT side of the business  are as good as it gets.

Alison Enns

Emilie Cote

Bryn Neally

There are a number of young women in place at City Hall doing very good work: Alison Enns, Bryn Neally, and Emilie Cote – the City is lucky to have them.

As good as these people are they need leadership and at this point that leadership is not coming from the City Manager or City Council elected in 2022.

Very hard to have a strong sense of confidence as Council returns to the Council Chamber on Monday to carry out the business of the City with a Mayor in the Chair operating under the Strong Mayor powers given last July running what has become a one person show.

Salt with Pepper is the musings, reflections and opinions of the publisher of the Burlington Gazette, an online newspaper that was formed in 2010 and is a member of the National Newsmedia Council.

Return to the Front page

One image, one face, one American moment: The Donald Trump mug shot

By JONATHAN J. COOPER

August 25th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

A camera clicks. In a fraction of a second, the shutter opens and then closes, freezing forever the image in front of it.

Associated Press

When the camera shutter blinked inside a jail in downtown Atlanta on Thursday, it both created and documented a tiny inflection point in American life. Captured for posterity, there was a former president of the United States, for the first time in history, under arrest and captured in the sort of frame more commonly associated with drug dealers or drunken drivers. The trappings of power gone, for that split second.

Left behind: an enduring image that will appear in history books long after Donald Trump is gone.

“It will be forever part of the iconography of being alive in this time,” said Marty Kaplan, a professor at the University of Southern California Annenberg School of Communications.

Mug shot of Donald Trump shows scowling former president during speedy booking at Atlanta jail

This booking photo provided by Fulton County Sheriff’s Office, shows former President Donald Trump on Thursday, Aug. 24, 2023, after he surrendered and was booked at the Fulton County Jail in Atlanta. Trump is accused by District Attorney Fani Willis of scheming to subvert the will of Georgia voters in a desperate bid to keep Joe Biden out of the White House. (Fulton County Sheriff’s Office via AP)

Trump has surrendered for a fourth time this year. Here’s where all the cases against him stand

Former President Donald Trump’s supporters gather outside of the Fulton County Jail, Thursday, Aug. 24, 2023, in Atlanta. (AP Photo/Brynn Anderson)
Dozens of Trump supporters cheer him on as former president turns himself in at Georgia jail

In the photo, Trump confronts the camera in front of a bland gray backdrop, his eyes meeting the lens in an intense glare. He’s wearing a blue suit, white shirt and red tie, his shoulders squared, his head tilted slightly toward the camera. The sheriff’s logo has been digitally added above his right shoulder.

Some of the 18 others charged with him in Georgia smiled in their booking photos like they were posing for a yearbook. Not Trump. His defiance is palpable, as if he’s staring down a nemesis through the lens.

“It is not a comfortable feeling — especially when you’ve done nothing wrong,” he later told Fox News Digital about the moment.

NOT LIKE ANY OTHER PHOTOGRAPH

Trump facing charges is by now a familiar sight of 2023 to Americans who watched him stand before a judge in a New York courtroom or saw watercolor sketches from the inside of federal courthouses in Miami and Washington, where cameras aren’t allowed.

This is different.

As Anderson Cooper put it on CNN: “The former president of the United States has an inmate number.” P01135809, to be exact. But until he surrendered to face charges of trying to steal the 2020 election in Georgia, his fourth indictment this year, he avoided having to pose for the iconic booking photo like millions accused of crimes before him.

Never mind that Trump, like all Americans, is innocent until proven guilty in court; the mug shot, and all it connotes, packs an extra emotional and cultural punch.

A mug shot is a visceral representation of the criminal justice system, a symbol of lost freedom. It permanently memorializes one of the worst days of a person’s life, a moment not meant for a scrapbook. It must be particularly foreign to a man born into privilege, who famously loves to be in control, who is highly attentive to his image and who rose to be the most powerful figure in the world.

“`Indictment’ is a sort of bloodless word. And words are pale compared to images,” said Kaplan, a former speechwriter for Vice President Walter Mondale and Hollywood screenwriter. “A mug shot is a genre. Its frame is, `This is a deer caught in the headlights. This is the crook being nailed.’ It’s the walk of shame moment.”

HE IS ALREADY LEVERAGING THE MOMENT

Trump is unlikely to treat the mug shot as a moment of shame as he seeks a second term in the White House while fighting criminal charges in four jurisdictions. His campaign has reported a spike in contributions each time he’s been indicted.

And the imagery itself? Trump hasn’t shied away from it. In fact, his campaign concocted one long before it became real.

Months before he was photographed in Georgia on Thursday evening, his campaign used the prospect of a mug shot as a fundraising opportunity. For $36, anyone can buy a T-shirt with a fake booking photo of Trump and the words “not guilty.” Dozens of similar designs are available to purchase online, including many that appeal to Trump’s critics.

Now they have a real one to work with. Within minutes of the mug shot’s release, Trump’s campaign used it in a fundraising appeal on its website. “BREAKING NEWS: THE MUGSHOT IS HERE,” reads the subject line of the campaign’s latest fundraising email, which advertises a new T-shirt with the image. And this quote: “This mugshot will forever go down in history as a symbol of America’s defiance of tyranny.”

In a show of solidarity, U.S. Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene posted to X, the platform formerly known as Twitter, a photo of herself smiling broadly in front of a gray background, the sheriff’s logo in the top left corner to mimic the jail’s style — essentially her DIY mug. “I stand with President Trump against the commie DA Fani Willis,” she said, a swipe at the Fulton County, Georgia, district attorney who persuaded a grand jury to indict Trump.

Recent history is full of politicians seeking political dividends from their booking photos. They’ve offered large smiles or defiant smirks and tried to make the best of their predicament.

Yet this is one of just 45 presidents in all of U.S. history — not only someone who held the keys to the most powerful government in the world, but who held a position that for many these days, both at home and overseas, personifies the United States. To see that face looking at a camera whose lens he is not seeking out — that’s a potent moment.

“There’s a power to the still image, which is inarguable,” said Mitchell Stevens, a professor emeritus at New York University who has written a book about the place imagery holds in modern society and how it is supplanting the word.

“It kind of freezes a moment, and in this case it’s freezing an unhappy moment for Donald Trump,” Stevens said. “And it’s not something he can click away. It’s not something he can simply brush off. That moment is going to live on. And it’s entirely possible that it will end up as the image that history preserves of this man.”

Return to the Front page

Wow!  That is egregious.  That is mean spirited and we suspect illegal.

By Pepper Parr

August 11th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

OPINION

More on that food chain and naturalized garden that the City weed-whacked recently

The belief on the part of staff at City hall that a bylaw was not being complied with are issues that “crop up” frequently.

What was astounding with the Karen Barnes situation was the decision on the part of the City to inform the holders of the mortgage she had on her property that she had not complied with a City bylaw.

Wow!  That is egregious.  That is mean spirited and we suspect illegal.

People who lend money want two things – they want their investment back with interest and they want to minimize their risk.

Interest rates are determined by the level of risk involved and the City of Burlington just told the money lenders that Karen Barnes was a bigger risk than they expected.

That is damnable.

We don’t know who made the decision to advise Barnes that they had sent a notice to her mortgage holder but we do believe that the work was done by the City’s legal department.  They would have to search the title to determine who held the mortgage and then craft and send the letter.

Brynn Nheiley, Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility was a part of the approving of the harsh decisions that were made.

Why the City Solicitor didn’t advise Brynn Nheiley, Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility  that it wasn’t a very good idea to send a letter like that is beyond me.

The timing of all this suggests that the work was done while Nancy Shea Nicol, now retired, was the City Solicitor at the time.

People like to feel that Staff at City hall are working for them – not against them. I wonder how Staff feel when they realize that someone has been treated in such a shabby manner.

The vegetation growing on Barnes’ front lawn and back yard wasn’t going to kill anyone.

The Statement found a way to avoid the facts.

The meanness that surrounds this is really very disturbing.

This is not what civilized, caring people do.

We wondered what the members of City Council would have to say when this became public – now we know where three of them stand.  The Joint Statement made by the Mayor and Councillors Nisan and Bentivegna was a disappointment. The statement itself has all the earmarks of a Meed Ward communiqué. It is overly long and does not directly address the main issue at hand – the manner in which the City executed its perceived mandate.

Related news stories

The beginning – what had happened before the weed whackers arrived

How did this happen

Salt with Pepper is the musings, reflections and opinions of the publisher of the Burlington Gazette, an online newspaper that was formed in 2010 and is a member of the National Newsmedia Council.

Return to the Front page

How did this happen? Mayor issues a statement - deflects rather than address the issue

By Pepper Parr

August 9th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

The response to the article on the woman who had a garden at the front and back of her house  weed-whacked by the city has been interesting.

We will follow the steps that her legal counsel takes to right what many see as a serious wrong.

Our interest at this point is – how did this happen?

Brynn Nheiley, Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility

Kerry Davren, Director of Bylaw Enforcement .

Who made the decisions?

Where was the oversight?

Burlington’s bylaw compliance policy is – or was at one point, to respond to complaints. “We don’t go looking for situations where a bylaw is not being conformed to.  We get a complaint and we investigate and try very hard to explain to people where the problems is and what they need to do.”

The impression we got at the time was that the bylaw enforcement people look for ways to solve a problem assuming in many cases people were just not aware that they were not conforming to the bylaw.

Let’s follow that thread.

Someone calls the bylaw department and registers a complaint.  Someone in the department takes down the details (is there a form they use – some way of capturing the information?)

A naturalized area is defined as “an area or vegetation deliberately planted or cultivated with one or more species of wildflowers, shrubs, annuals, perennials, ornamental grasses, or combination of them, that is monitored and maintained by a person.

Then a bylaw officer is assigned the task of meeting with the person making the complaint.

Did that happen in this instance ?

At some point Kerry Devron, who at the time was the Manager of Bylaw Enforcement, has to make a decision.

There is little doubt in our mind that Ms Devron would have taken the complaint to the Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility  and sought some direction.

Back in October when the issue became real – by which we mean there was a complaint and some action was taken by the department and that at some point the Executive Director was brought into the loop.

We now know that the City legal department was in the loop as far back is as last October.  David Donnelly, a lawyer, who was very familiar with the issue – he had in the past defended, successfully we might add, provided the legal department with the existing case law.

All this happened before the beginning of August.

Why is that important?  On August 3rd, the City announced that Kerry Devron was being promoted to the position of Director of the newly created By Law Enforcement Department.

We the elected and the staff that serve the public are not punching bags. Tax payers – that’s a different issue.

So, everything Ms Devron did was as a Manager.

Managers don’t make decisions that advise a citizen that they could be facing a fine of $10,000 per day.

And Managers don’t advise a citizen that should they obstruct city staff from doing what they were required to do that they could be facing a fine of $100,000

So, if Ms Devron, a manager didn’t make the decisions – who did?

Move up the food chain to the Executive Director.

One final question?  Who decided to inform the company that holds the mortgage on the property that Karen Barnes might not be complying with the City bylaws?

Who sent that issue to the legal department – and why did the legal department accept the assignment?

That’s enough in the way of questions for today.

We expect to be moving further up the food chain on this one.

Mayor Meed Ward along with Councillors Nisan and Bentivegna issued the following Joint Statement:

Our offices have been receiving questions from residents regarding the City of Burlington allowing for naturalized gardens on properties, based on an article that appeared in the Toronto Star over the weekend. We appreciate the concerns members of the community have been raising regarding naturalized gardens and environmental protections in Burlington – we share them. That is why the City of Burlington updated our Lot Maintenance Bylaw in 2018 to allow for naturalized gardens and again in 2022 to clarify regulations that apply to naturalized gardens.

There are numerous examples of naturalized gardens in neighbourhoods across our City that are operating within our bylaw. Such gardens are regularly maintained and pruned, have no other non-conforming weeds growing, and no invasive species being grown. Examples of non-conforming weeds come from the definitions of noxious weeds that are set by the Province of Ontario under the Weed Control Act.

We welcome and support these gardens and appreciate residents who maintain them within City and Provincial standards.

We will do our best to continue to educate residents about naturalized gardens, invasive species, and lot maintenance responsibilities. Our bylaw allows for naturalized gardens and those gardens must conform to lot maintenance standards. Each complaint the City receives is investigated and treated the same under the terms of our bylaw. We will also defend our City bylaws in a balanced and impartial manner. When the City investigates a complaint, it provides the property owner with information regarding the requirements of the bylaw, where they may not be in compliance, and continues to work with them until compliance is achieved within reasonable timelines.

Only when that process fails, and as a last resort, would charges be filed with the court. Fines, up to a maximum, established by the Province and adopted by the City, may be imposed by a Court on an owner of any property found in non-compliance with the bylaw. The amount of the potential fines is included in all notices for transparency.

The recent Star story listed a property that does not comply with our bylaw for naturalized gardens. It has been under formal and extensive City of Burlington bylaw investigation and enforcement since 2015. The City has attempted to work closely with the property owners to bring their property into compliance with our bylaws. In doing so, the City consulted with experts in naturalized gardens. This matter was recently before the courts and the ruling was in the City’s favour.

We invite Burlington residents to review our bylaws and provide feedback and suggestions, if they have any. We also recommend the community reviews the Province’s Table of Noxious Weeds and shares any suggestions they have regarding those regulations with their local MPP.

We appreciate the opportunity to engage with the community on this important environmental matter, to reassure residents that naturalized gardens are welcome in Burlington and to share information about how residents can ensure these conform with our City’s bylaws.

The Joint Statement doesn’t appear to suggest that this issue can be worked out amicably.  Karen Barnes is going to need financial support.  She has created a site where the environmentalist can help.

Click on the image if you think you want to help.

Return to the Front page

Told that she could be fined $10,000 a day for not complying with a bylaw the City then advises her mortgage holder of the infraction

By Pepper Parr

August 8th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

What do you do when seven people from city hall show up on your doorstep – no notice and tell you they are going to cut what they claim are weeds on your front lawn and back yard?

The group of seven didn’t bother to knock on the door – they just began cutting.  This is the situation Karen Barnes found herself facing on June 20th.

Barnes decided in 2015 to create a natural garden, one that respected the environment and would become a place where Monarch butterflies would stop over on the annual migration to Mexico.

Her difficulty with the City started back in October of this year when she got a notice from the city about the plants in the garden.

On the left the garden in full bloom, on the right the garden which was described by city workers as nothing but weeds that they took out with a weed wacker.

Barnes has been in the house for 30 years; the natural garden was a decision she made eight years ago when it became clear to her that Climate Change meant changes in the way we were living on this planet were necessary.

In a media release sent to the Toronto Star exclusively Barnes said: “The law is very clear, I have a right to grow this garden consistent with my sincerely held beliefs. I’ve met with the City and hired an expert to demonstrate I’m complying with the By-law. I want an investigation into these bullying tactics.”

Karen Barnes is a sensitive soul. When she talks to people her natural gesture is a hand on their arm or shoulder. She said: “It’s kind of humiliating too, because this is our public-facing expression of our beliefs and people who are just coming by, they’re not going to know the city did this. They’re going to think it’s a decision we made and that’s not the expression that we want to have to the world.”

Karen Barnes, who has a master’s degree in ecology from McMaster University, said one of the crew members told her: “We’re just cutting the grass.” But to her and her daughter, it was the destruction of a habitat that has brought them both joy since 2015, when they first allowed native plants to return; an approach experts call “passive restoration” — and evolved into maintaining the naturalized space.

“Purple asters came, milkweed came and the bylaw at the time allowed for all this,”

“Purple asters came, milkweed came and the bylaw at the time allowed for all this,” she said, describing how the plants led to visits from endangered monarch butterflies and other species.

Barnes has known David Donnelly for a number of years. He is a lawyer specializing in environment issues – he handled the PERL (Protecting Escarpment and Rural Land) case against Nelson Quarry over their application for an extension of the land they could mine.

The joint tribunal that heard the case found for the PERL group.

Donnelly also worked with the people who wanted a stop put to the plans to cut several thousand trees on the Meridian Brick works people. While there was no definitive decision – so far nothing has been cut.

There was a point when, as ward 2 Councillor, Marianne Meed Ward was all over that issue with her support. As Mayor she hasn’t had much to say.

Donnelly got in touch with the people at City hall, explained the legislation that secured the rights of those who wanted a natural garden. At the time Donnelly thought the city now understood what they could and couldn’t do – and the issue seemed to have come to an end.

Then, on May 26, of 2023, the city issued a notice of non-compliance with several bylaws, including the 20-centimetre rule, with just 11 days to meet a deadline to rectify the alleged problems.

That 20 centimetre rule requires that the height of a plant cannot be more than 20 centimetres high.

On June 4th, Barnes got a letter from the City advising her that she had until June 6th to comply with the bylaw.

One June 20th seven people showed and began cutting the natural garden.

Karen Barnes on the left with her daughter Julia. The wire baskets on the lawn were where the naturalized plants were located. “We felt we were violated” said Karen

What the Barnes’s and her lawyer say is a purposeful, naturalized garden — restored and planted to help bees and butterflies, nature’s pollinators, and increase biodiversity in their corner of Burlington was permitted — according to the city, the garden was violating several bylaws.

After the City first notified Barnes that her yard was not in compliance back in October, she spoke with Donnelly, who in turn spoke with the city’s lawyer. Donnelly said he provided the case law allowing such spaces and, as requested, an expert report on the property’s naturalized area.

The Barnes family had maintained a yard of goldenrod, coneflower, wood poppy, purple asters and milkweed — that was until the City of Burlington sent crews to level what they called “weeds.”

Despite the talks taking place the City crew arrived with landscaping equipment and went to work, leaving sections of the front yard levelled as well as parts of the backyard. Karen Barnes and her daughter Julia said they were left feeling “violated.”

The growing the goldenrod, coneflower and wood poppy, along with other native species, were not in compliance with a rule to maintain all vegetation under 20 centimetres, among other infractions which the homeowners dispute. As a penalty, the city had threatened an astonishing $10,000-a-day fine until the yard was remedied to their standards.  They added that a fine of $100,000 could be levied if Barnes tried to obstruct the City workers.

David Donnelly. prominent environment lawyer is representing Karen Barnes.

“Burlington has a deserved reputation for respecting the environment and homeowners that are doing something about the climate crisis by creating pollinator habitat, reducing the need for mowing, and other stewardship measures. Writing Ms. Barnes’ mortgage company is disgraceful conduct that needs to be investigated, as the by-law doesn’t give the City this authority”, Donnelly added.

Donnelly was quoted in the Toronto Star saying: “Giving butterflies a safe haven, you want to fine them $10,000 a day? It’s perverse.”

Barnes said: ““We want to show that you can work with nature and have a positive, supportive relationship.”

The city, for its part, says that despite allowances for naturalized areas in the city’s bylaw, the Barnes’ yard “did not meet the definition,” and that the City has the authority to enforce its bylaws on private property.

The municipal war over naturalized gardens and a focus on conformity is not unique to Burlington — though Donnelly called the threatened fine unprecedented.

These types of bylaw issues are usually driven by complaints — a neighbour who, maybe seeing the yard as an eyesore or unable to differentiate between weeds and pollinator species or complaints about what they think is a lack of maintenance.

According to Burlington’s own lot-maintenance bylaw, a naturalized area is defined as “an area or vegetation deliberately planted or cultivated with one or more species of wildflowers, shrubs, annuals, perennials, ornamental grasses, or combination of them, that is monitored and maintained by a person.”

Such areas, the bylaw says, are excluded from the rule to maintain lots with plants more than 20 centimetres or less — many native species naturally grow much taller, like the goldenrod stalks still standing in the front yard.

As outrageous as this sounds – it gets worse.

Today, the 8th of August Kerry Davren starts her new job is as Director of Bylaw Enforcement. Prior to the promotion Davren was the city’s manager of bylaw enforcement. At that time she said the order issued to the Barns said that the city may carry out the work at the homeowner’s expense if it was not complied with, as allowed by the city’s bylaws.

Kerry Davren, with 14 years of experience starts her new job is as Director of Bylaw Enforcement today.

Davren said bylaw officers are “appointed as weed inspectors in accordance with the Weed Control Act” which requires certification and training on plant identification, and sent a photo of the property before “the weeds were trimmed.”

Davren did not respond to a question about whether it’s common practice to contact a homeowner’s mortgage company.

Brynn Nheiley, Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility

Brynn Nheiley, Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility explains why she hired Kerry Davren “Kerry’s breadth of experiences will be a great asset to the City of Burlington as she leads the newly established Bylaw Compliance Department. Demonstrating compassion, logic and professionalism, Kerry continues to highlight and respond to evolving needs of the Burlington community. She is highly respected by her staff, City Council and the Burlington Leadership Team.”

Given the performance by Davren when she was a Manager one wonders what she will do is as a Director.

The case law, which Donnelly provided to the City of Burlington back in the fall, includes a 1990s Toronto case in which bylaws were successfully challenged on the basis that they infringed the Charter right to freedom of expression. Donnelly explained these rulings set out that as long as a naturalized garden is a “conscientious” or purposeful expression of one’s beliefs, it is permitted under Canadian law.

Donnelly said they plan to challenge the City of Burlington’s application of the bylaw in court as unconstitutional. He added that it’s unclear what fines or costs the Barnes currently face.

When there is an issue that a community finds is unfair support comes quite quickly.
A Fund Raiser has been started to raise the $25,000 they feel will be needed to take the case to Court and any appeals that might ensue.

Karen Barnes has chosen Small Change as their fund raiser.  Click on the Small Change Fund image if you want to support getting to the bottom of what happened and why.

Karen Barnes has yet to see the Barbie movie.

The interview with Barns was lengthy, interrupted more than once when she asked for a moment to get a grip on her emotions. We wanted to know what Karen did in her spare time; what did she read, where did she spend her spare time? . She paused and I wasn’t sure she was going to answer the question so I asked if she had yet seen the Barbie movie that is a bit of a rage right now.

She responded – I didn’t know there was a Barbie movie – why would someone do something like that – and then she burst into laughter.

This is going to be an interesting story – it certainly has legs.

Return to the Front page

City selects Kerry Davren as new Director of Bylaw Compliance

By Staff

August 3rd, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

Kerry Davren is the new Director of Bylaw Compliance.

Kerry Davren, new Director of Bylaw Compliance. Brings a measure of compassion to the job – always nice to see.

Davren has been employed by the City of Burlington for a total of 14 years. In her time at the City, Davren has held various positions including Transportation Planner & Technologist and Manager of Transportation Planning & Parking. In her most recent position as Manager of Bylaw Services, Davren oversaw the development, interpretation and administration of enforcement activities related to municipal bylaws, as well as provincial and federal legislation.

Davren has a total of 26 years of experience working in municipal government, including at the City of Hamilton as the Manager of Parking Operations and Strategic Initiatives where she supported the development and implementation of a city-wide Parking Master Plan. Davren also worked for the Town of Oakville as a Project Leader supporting projects related to roadway design and construction. Her extensive municipal experience enables her to navigate the complexities of regulatory enforcement, liaise effectively with various stakeholders, and develop policies that support the Burlington community.

As Director of the Bylaw Compliance Department, Davren will oversee the enforcement and compliance of municipal bylaws and provide recommendations to City Council and City’s leadership team related to implementing policies that support the City’s strategic goals.

Within this portfolio, Davren will support Bylaw Compliance, Animal Control and Licensing & Regulatory Services.

Davren has a Bachelor of Arts from McMaster University and a Diploma in Transportation Engineering Technology from Mohawk College. Davren is also a Certified Engineering Technologist.

Davren will begin in her new role on Aug. 8.

Brynn Nheiley, Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility explains why she hired the woman: “Kerry’s breadth of experiences will be a great asset to the City of Burlington as she leads the newly established Bylaw Compliance Department. Demonstrating compassion, logic and professionalism, Kerry continues to highlight and respond to evolving needs of the Burlington community. She is highly respected by her staff, City Council and the Burlington Leadership Team. I extend my congratulations to Kerry as the successful candidate.”

Return to the Front page

Acting Director Jamie Tellier announced as new Director of Community Planning

By Pepper Parr

June 13th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

The City of Burlington is pleased to announce the promotion of Jamie Tellier as the City’s new of Director of Community Planning.

Finally – he should have taken the job when he had the chance. If anyone knows community, understand community and actually likes community it is Jamie Tellier

Site Planning co-coordinator Jamie Tellier explains what is going to be built whereon the JBMH campus.

Tellier was chosen as the successful candidate following an extensive and competitive recruitment. As the Acting Director Community Planning, he demonstrated strategic leadership, collaborating to achieve successful outcomes and a continuous improvement mindset.

Jamie has been with the City for 21 years. He has progressed through various leadership roles in Community Planning, including two extended roles as Acting Director of Community Planning.

Over the next six months in particular, Tellier will focus on strategic priorities that are currently underway in Community Planning:

• Recruiting and developing talent to meet the growing needs of Burlington,
• Adapting the City’s organizational, policy and regulatory frameworks to adjust our work to comply with recent legislative changes, such as Bill 23,
• Introducing more tools, such as MyFiles, to improve how we do business with residents and developers to be more efficient and transparent and
• Foster a culture of collaboration between staff, partners and customers for mutual success.

Most recently, as the Manager of Planning Implementation, Tellier led a number of Continuous Improvement initiatives for the City’s Development Services area. These projects, which resulted in improved service to applicants and better outcomes for Council, residents and staff, include:

Jamie Tellier is one of the few staff members who gets excited about the work he does. You always know he loves the job he is doing. Knows how to solve a problem.

• Leading Development Services staff to develop a new Pre-Building Approval application process.
• Respond to and adapt the development application processes for Official Plan Amendments, Zoning Bylaw Amendments and Site Plan Applications. This positions the City to better respond to new provincial legislations, such as Bill 23.
• Enhance Community Planning’s teamwork with the Burlington Digital Services Department (ITS) to come up with innovative solutions to better serve the community and allow staff to focus on the development review process.

Before joining the City in 2002, Tellier worked as a planner in Palm Beach County, Florida. He has a Masters of Urban Design Studies from the University of Toronto and a Bachelor of Environmental Studies with Honours in Urban and Regional Planning from the University of Waterloo.

Jamie Tellier as seen by a city photographer: Terrible picture Jamie – you shouldn’t have let them do this to you.

Tellier will continue to work with the Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility Service Group and report to the Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility.

Brynn Nheiley, Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility got it right wen she said: “I very much look forward to continuing to work closely with Jamie as he adjusts from Acting to permanent Director. He is a wealth of corporate and departmental knowledge, innovative ideas and is very skilled at responding to the evolving challenges faced by the Community Planning department and the City.

“I would like to thank Jamie for assuming the Acting Director role these past six months, as well as big thanks to Amanda D’Angelo and Kyle Plas for taking on additional duties and responsibilities to support and maintain the high productivity of the Community Planning Department during this time.

“I am very pleased to have Jamie permanently join the Burlington Leadership Team, bringing his wealth of skills, knowledge and perspectives to the table.”

 

Return to the Front page

Staff take Council through a Workshop where ideas were popping out all over the place.

By Pepper Parr

April 20th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

Earlier this week Staff did a work shop that included Council.

It was an interesting and refreshing approach that had staff setting out their issues and explaining to council just what they were up against.

The Workshop included 30 graphics, one of which is set out below, that took Council through a very detailed presentation with more depth than usual.

 

Changing the setting proved to be a smart idea – there was much better communication once the administrative restrictions were removed.

Two two blue boxes:  Mindset of open to change and Pause in New Staff Directions are not the kind of thing that was seen in the past.

There is a refreshing change taking place.  The leadership at the Executive Director level is much better.

During the half day event Brynn Nheiley, Executive Director of Community Planning, Regulation and Mobility, had Council doing some role playing followed by a very casual, almost family living room setting, where questions were asked and comments made without a Chair in place directing the conversation.

Nheiley went from being Manager of Development & Design in the Community Planning Department to becoming an Executive Director. As the Manager of Development & Design, she led a number of initiatives that has led to improvements in development planning that support better outcomes for Council, residents and staff; these include:

  • Establishing a two-stage reporting strategy in order to provide Council with the opportunity to make a decision on an application within the legislated timeline, while also enabling the flexibility for staff to work with applicants to create the best planning outcome for development applications.
  • Bringing together staff from key departments to collaboratively build a development review process that gives applicants a single point of contact, and single application to satisfy multiple pre-approvals, from multiple departments, which are required before a building permit can be applied for.
  • Bringing together a management team that included staff from building, planning, forestry, site engineering and Information Technology Services departments in order to launch an entirely digital review process for all forms of development applications. The result was that the City’s development review process was delayed by less than two months from the start of the Covid-19 pandemic.

Prior to working at the City of Burlington, Brynn worked for the City of Hamilton as a Senior Planner and as the Acting Director of Planning and Building Services for the Town of Antigonish in Nova Scotia.  Brynn has a Masters of Planning from Dalhousie University and a Bachelor of Architectural Science from Ryerson University.

The Workshop ended with this slide.

 

Return to the Front page