By Pepper Parr
BURLINGTON, ON. July 28, 2013. Comments are an integral part of a newspaper on a website. The ability for anyone to write their opinion right alongside a news item they like or dislike and have that comment stay with the story is a tool that makes public discourse that much more robust.
However, there are some rules. You do not HAVE to tell the public who you are. You can use a “pen” name” but why you would not have the courage of your convictions and be prepared to tell people who you are is beyond me.
Passionate it was – it was also honest and open dialogue about a major city issue.
When a comment comes to us we have to approve each and every one. We test the email address the comment was sent to us from; a significant number fail. People make up an email address and send their message knowing that we can never get back to them.
We do capture their IP (Internet Protocol) address and in the hands of an authority the sender of the message can be traced.
At the Gazette we want to see honest, committed, passionate dialogue between people whose views may differ. We want to see new ideas and viewpoints that would not get expression in traditional media.
We have no problem with a tight, tart comment – call them “zingers” if you wish; they add colour to the public debate. We do however have a responsibility to ensure that the dialogue is fair and honest.
We test the email address a comment comes from; if the address proves to be invalid the comment does not get posted.
On occasion we have posted a comment from an email address that was not valid and added an editorial note advising that we could not verify the sender but felt the comment was worth making part of the public discourse.
Citizens gather for budget discussions. This meeting involved a number of city firemen who were attentively listened to by Councillor Craven, on the right in the blue shirt.
We have had comments from members of the clergy, the legal profession and senior staff members at various levels of government, who, because of the jobs are not authorized to comment. We will publish their comments if we feel they are a legitimate part of the debate.
We have regular contributors to the comments section, many who make very legitimate comment and several who are very good at catching our mistakes – all are valued and welcome.
Those who want to make a comment they know not to be true; those who want to disrupt and deliberately hurt a private citizen – they are not welcome.
Those who want to be able to hold civil servants and elected officials to account – let us hear from you frequently.
