By Pepper Parr
January 19th, 2021
BURLINGTON, ON
When the Corporate Services, Strategy, Risk and Accountability Committee was ready to adjourn last week after recommending that the Capital budget be approved, Ward 6 Councillor Angelo Bentivegna, who voted against the $80million Capital budget, said he was disappointed but that “he would get over it”.
Lisa Kearns – before she was a member of city council.
Lisa Kearns, Councillor for Ward 2 said: This was a big exercise, a challenge for all of us noting that there wasn’t a single delegation adding that it was evident the public trusted council.
Tom Muir, a frequent Gazette commenter didn’t see it quite that way and said: “I think that Lisa does not have the full sense of what she claimed about everyone being budget happy just because no one showed up.
“False logic indeed.
Tom Muir brings decades of experience in municipal matters to his thinking.
“Has she completely forgotten that COVID has changed everything, including public engagement and delegations. There’s no real life left in these things.
“You don’t get to meet with all the people, see the body language all around, group conversations before and after, feel the sense of the room and so on. Now that’s fact as we all know, but it goes to the heart of Lisa’s thoughtless (in my view) remark.
“In my experience, I have no actionable desire to delegate to these virtual meetings, and especially, at this time, about the budget. This budget document is very large and takes a very long time to read, and even longer if you want to criticize. People more or less can’t really do this, and with COVID have indicated so.
“I have done so in the past and from the reaction I got it was a waste of time.
“I still see the percent increase expressed in terms of the overall Regional and Education budget amounts. This increase and the way it is expressed is a perennial complaint from people – the answer is always: we are looking into it. Doubling the tax take for Burlington is not a concern of City.
Tom Muir: Knows false logic when he sees it.
“Also, I still see $43 million budgeted for transit for buses (16 new and 52 replacements) that for many routes nobody rides. Good to go to Hamilton and back but that’s about all. What I have been told is that they are working on it and walking, busing and biking – the integrated mobility plan – is the future.
“Has anyone up there given any thought to COVID changing all of the basis of all of the planning that is based on getting back to “normal”? I see no signs of this anywhere, including, especially, the province, who wants to double down on the past, no change.
“But of course, COVID is busting budgets all over, and we have to pay. These holes are getting deeper and deeper and will have to be paid back and this will take a long time. Like it or not, COVID, being global, will be endemic and mutating, and is not going away.
“The economy and society we had is basically not compatible and sustainable without drastic changes, but I only see these changes being forced by the virus, and not in the plans and policies that I see that only try to support what exists.
“Reopening the economy, or trying to, will be another dangerous time in the not too distant future. I have said before that we cannot have an economy that works until we eliminate this virus.
“The only real cold comfort I get from the budget future is that I trust Joan Ford. Chief Financial Officer to figure it out.”
Perhaps it is “Delegation Fatigue? Prior to the last municipal election residents came together and delegated for change in the way things were happening at City Hall and at Council.
Residents brought change to the Council by voting in a new mayor and 5 new councillors. Unfortunately many of the election promises have not come to fruition.
Is it any wonder that many of the more vocal residents have stepped away?
Not a single delegation is telling. Is engagement DOA?
As so often, Tom is bang on. And good observation about the transit trend and covid.
Agreed.