Feds want deputy ministers to shake conventional thinking on policy making and develop fresh perspectives on key issues

By Kathryn May

December 11th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

Canada’s top bureaucrat has assembled a dozen teams of deputy ministers to shake conventional thinking on policymaking and develop fresh perspectives on key issues the country will face over the next decade.

Privy council clerk John Hannaford assembled the teams, which have been meeting over the fall, on topics that include health and aging, confidence in institutions, reconciliation, artificial intelligence, productivity and economic growth, foreign affairs, combatting disinformation and misinformation, Canada and the US, and the future of the public service.

The policy exercise is said to be one of the broadest and most forward-looking in years. It is aimed at cross-pollinating ideas by involving all 80 deputy ministers and associate deputy ministers. They will be working in small groups on topics, often  outside their usual expertise and departmental portfolios.

The policy exercise is said to be one of the broadest and most forward-looking in years. It is aimed at cross-pollinating ideas by involving all 80 deputy ministers and associate deputy ministers. They will be working in small groups on topics, often  outside their usual expertise and departmental portfolios.

Each group is headed by an associate deputy minister who is free to organize discussions with no formal work plan from the Privy Council Office.

They have been meeting with the goal of delivering preliminary reports to the clerk in December which will feed into an agenda for a deputy ministers’ retreat in January.

Avoid rounding up the usual suspects

In a statement, PCO (Privy Council Office) said “a premium has been placed on engaging experts with diverse perspectives – not the ‘usual suspects.’” The teams are exploring multiple sides of the issues, including social, economic and global security implications, which form “our increasingly complex policy landscape.”

They will “assess gaps, blind spots, what are we missing” as well as possible opportunities for efficiency and innovation.

This policy exercise is separate from the deputy minister task team that Hannaford put together to lead a government-wide “dialogue” about values and ethics.

One associate deputy minister said daily issues, an ever-shortening news cycle, the pressure of delivering on the government’s platform promises means policymakers don’t get a chance to think enough about medium and long-term policy planning.

“Every day, it’s always a shiny new object to manage that becomes a challenge,” he said.

The exercise is a recognition that policymakers live in an age of upheaval with global, economic, social or environmental crises looming around every corner.

It also comes as departments begin transition planning for whatever government wins the next election and as the parties are putting together election platforms.

In an era of such uncertainty, “adaptive policymaking” are the new buzzwords for designing policies that respond to changing conditions. Policymakers are used to make decisions based on current realities – such as today’s demographics or GDP.

Daniel Quan-Watson, who spent nearly 15 years as a deputy minister until retiring last month, said that doesn’t work anymore. “It’s critical not to take as a given that the world will play out as it always has,” said Quan-Watson.

“This is about asking questions. What are we missing here? Are we seeing things the right way? Are we as equipped as we should be to engage with the things coming at us in the future?” he said.

The global polycrisis

Hannaford told a recent conference of policymakers he expects crises coming at governments, one after another, and at the same time, will continue in the coming decade. He predicts more geopolitical uncertainty, major technological change and climate disasters.

“How do we manage against a backdrop where there are multiple demands on us and each demand is really, really important. How do you figure out what needs to be at the top of the pile,” Hannaford said.

He said policymakers need to be flexible, adjust to problems as they arise and “not be thrown off if things do not follow precisely the plan that we thought.”

“We won’t solve things if we are rigid and simply approach things precisely the way we have always done,” said Hannaford.

The last time the public service took on a review of values and ethics was nearly thirty years ago. That’s when then clerk Jocelyne Bourgon created nine deputy minister task forces to look at big issues for the public service in the aftermath of Chrétien government’s sweeping program review to slay the deficit, which downsized the size of government and re-defined its role.

The task force on values and ethics produced the Tait report, the foundation of today’s code governing public service behaviour.

Bourgon also had a task force on the future of the public service and another on “Strengthening Our Policy Capacity,” which led to the creation of the Policy Research Initiative, a think-tank for medium-term research. It later became Policy Horizons Canada.

Diverse public service, diverse views

The latest exercise includes up to 80 deputy ministers and associate deputy ministers. Watson, the first deputy minister of Chinese-Canadian descent, said the leaders are among the most diverse in the bureaucracy’s history. They should deliver more insight than a group of deputies from the same background sitting at the table.

But some senior officials are frustrated and anxious to get on with tackling issues.

“We know the issues. I think we need to be really bold and get very good at execution. We know what to do, we just have to get on with it.”

Policy goes hand in hand with delivery – poor delivery sinks good policy and excellent delivery won’t save bad policy.

A deputy’s job is to deliver the government’s decisions and offer advice to help the government make those decisions. Figuring out what issues could come at you out of the blue will help in offering that advice,” said one deputy minister.

But the public service is hard-wired to work in certain ways when it comes to hiring and purchasing and a host of other issues. These ways of doing things don’t always work in a rapidly changing world.

Over the decades, the public service underwent a build-up of rules and faced a growing posse of watchdogs to police their work, which stifled innovation and risk-taking. On top of that, public servants face a new layer of political control with the growth of political and ministerial staff.

Kathryn May is the Accenture Fellow on the Future of the Public Service, providing coverage and analysis of the complex issues facing Canada’s federal public service for Policy Options. She has spent 25 years writing about the public service – the country’s largest workforce.  The winner of a National Newspaper Award, she has also researched and written about public service issues for the federal government and research institutes. Follow Kathryn on Twitter: @kathryn_may.
Return to the Front page

Delegating at city hall: Rules of that game need some changes

By Pepper Parr

December 11th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

People who delegate at city council have frequently had a concern with the way agenda items are placed on the Consent list.

Jim Thomson, a frequent delegator upset the Chair of a meeting and was escorted out of the Council Chamber. He is limited now to delegating virtually during which they at times have to cut his mike.

On a number of occasions recently the issue has been brought up.

Last week at the Env Standing Committee Chair Rory Nisan (Councillor for ward 3 – who lives in ward 2 said he “wanted to address the question about consent items with respect to delegations. Section 35.1 of the Procedural bylaw, which is the Bible Council has to direct how they conduct the business of the city.

Nisan has taken the position that 35.1 says:”Items that will be placed on the consent agenda include, but are not limited to those with no delegations where no discussion is anticipated, I informational items and routine matters.

Councillor Rory Nisan

Nisan then said: “As chair the way I read that, although it could be more elegantly worded, and we can revise, but it’s pretty clear that items placed on the consent agenda include but are not limited to those with no delegation. The fact that a delegation occurs does not mean it must be put on the taken off the consent agenda.

“That’s how I interpreted it. That’s how we’ll be interpreting it today. Committee always has the opportunity to overrule the chair.”

Nisan got the concern out into the open.  Sometime in the New Year we might see a change in the Procedural Bylaw; something that needs more than a few cosmetic changes.

 

 

 

Return to the Front page

Provincial goal of building 1.5 million homes will not be realized without adequate land supply

By Pepper Parr

December 11, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

A report released last week said: the Provincial goal of building 1.5 million homes will not be realized without adequate land supply

That doesn’t come as a surprise.  How the province is going to react and what can, in reality, be done is the very pressing issue.

Is this where new housing should be built?

The study by Malone Given Parsons Ltd. (MGP), commissioned for the Building Industry and Land Development Association (BILD) and the Ontario Home Builders’ Association (OHBA) and supported by the West End Home Builders’ Association (WE HBA), identifies that there is insufficient land within municipal official plans in the Greater Golden Horseshoe (GGH) and Greater Toronto Area to meet mid- and long-term population growth. This will jeopardize the provincial objective of building 1.5 million new homes and undermine efforts to address housing supply and affordability.

“The need for additional land supply has been clearly identified by planning experts as necessary to accommodate population growth and limit the continued displacement of residents,” said Mike Collins-Williams, WE HBA CEO. “Local political opposition and disruptions in our planning system make it increasingly difficult to bring new ground-oriented housing online.”

In what way is the WE HBA using the phrase “new ground-oriented housing”?  Are they talking about just single or semi- detached homes? Because that is not the kind of development the policy people seem to be talking about.

WE HBA represents the interests of the home building community that has a lot of land that housing can be built on.  There financial interests are best served through the construction of ground-oriented housing where the return on their land investments is significant.

The  Malone Given Parsons report adds that there are “challenges in adding supply within cities, meaning we are nearly 80,000 housing units short (2006-2021) of where we should be in the Greater Toronto and Hamilton Area (GTHA). Without an aggressive approach to building, we can anticipate this shortfall to increase.”

This is the kind of housing that is being built – a different kind of community and we need to get it right the first time – not something planners have a lot of experience with.

The report identifies that even before the province reversed the approval of municipal official plans, the housing shortfall would increase to an estimated 97,000 grade-related housing units (including singles, semis and all forms of townhouses). Following the reduction of land supply by the 2023 provincial “reversal” of local official plans, the housing shortfall could increase to 206,800 grade-related homes (10,400 ha) plus any shortfall in apartment growth.

MGP’s study further identifies that in absence of expanding municipal boundaries to add land for grade-related homes, the redevelopment of vast quantities of existing neighbourhoods would be required to accommodate growth. Based on the municipally adopted official plans, to be “reset” by the province that include little to no additional land for new settlement area boundary expansion areas, the shortfall in grade-related housing units would require 10 per cent of all existing low-density neighbourhoods to be redeveloped to accommodate growth to the year 2051.

“Given that the GTHA accommodates over 30 per cent of Canada’s immigration each year, because immigration is the primary driver of population growth in Canada, a shortfall of housing has national implications,” said Neil Rodgers, OHBA Interim Chief Executive Officer. “The province has a policy statement to guide development for future growth. It commissioned extensive growth and housing requirement projections to help plan to 2051. This study demonstrates that by ignoring its own policies and projections, decisions made today are going to have far-reaching implications and show that we will be in a demand/supply imbalance for decades to come – continuously pushing prices up. If we’re to address the affordability crisis now, we need solutions that increase supply, support transit-supported infrastructure and housing choices on shorter timelines.”

“WE HBA along with our partners at BILD and the OHBA are calling on the Ontario Government and municipal governments across the province to ensure that housing affordability and supply are addressed by making sufficient lands available for a market-based supply of housing to meet forecasted growth needs to the planning horizon of 2051. In addition, they are calling on the government to establish a transparent, modern and stable planning system, which is required to realize the forecasted growth in the GGH.”

It was the need for additional land that led to the Greenbelt fiasco that is now under investigation by the RCMP.  Besides the possibility that some people might be charged criminally, the really stupid decisions made, and the even stupider way Cabinet handled the matter has spoiled the trust that was necessary between a government and the people who vote.

 

 

 

Return to the Front page

Real Estate Rule Changes now Allow Option for Sellers to use an Open Bidding Process

By Pepper Parr

December 10th,2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

New rules for Ontario real estate are coming into force that are meant to provide more clarity and choice for buyers and sellers.

The rules, which took effect Friday, include the option for sellers to use an open bidding process, improvements to broker and brokerage disclosures, and ways to avoid conflicts on multiple representation.

The open bidding option gives the seller the choice to disclose submitted bid prices to potential buyers, something they were previously banned from doing.

Open bidding has been advocated by some as a way to reduce rampant overbidding in real estate and help reduce prices.

There are those that believe a consistently transparent bidding process will help bring down the skyrocketing price of houses.

The federal Liberals also promised in their 2021 election campaign to end blind bidding because it said not knowing other bids ultimately drives up home prices.

Joseph Richer, registrar at the Real Estate Council of Ontario, said there’s little research on how blind bidding affects prices, adding there are some indications that open auctions in Australia put upward pressure on prices.

He also said mandating open bidding could lead to negative effects for sellers.

“Keep in mind that in every transaction, there’s a buyer and a seller, and that whatever you mandate for one, might be, and probably is at the detriment of the other.”

Making it optional gives more options to sellers, Richer said.

“We don’t anticipate a big market swing. It might help some parties in some transactions.”

Sellers who are having trouble finding buyers might want to allow their agent to disclose bids to attract more, he pointed out as an example.

The option doesn’t look that appealing to most sellers in the current market, but real estate agents will likely find some uses, said Randy Oickle, president of Innovation Realty Ltd. in Kanata, Ont.

“(There’s) likely going to be some new business models that come along to try to take advantage of new possibilities.”

He said he would have liked to see some rules around the process of using open bidding.

“The fact that there’s no sort of framework for using it, I think potentially creates challenges.”

Oickle said, overall, he sees the changes in the act as quite significant.

Other notable parts of the law include the ability to choose a designated representative.

Previously, if the buyer and sellers’ agents worked at the same brokerage, then, given the potential conflict of interest, they would fall under a multiple representation scenario. In these cases, agents were generally only able to act as facilitators, and were limited on how much they could advise clients, including on what is a good price.

By designating specific agents, the buyer and seller under the new rules would free themselves from multiple representation, and agents could advocate more actively on their behalf, said Richer.

“It allows you, if I hire you, you now are free to continue to advocate for me and to offer the services and all your experience that you can bring to bear on my behalf, which you were prohibited from doing under multiple representation.”

The updates, Phase 2 of changes under the act, also include an amended code of ethics, new enforcement tools for RECO, and an information guide from the agency that prospective clients are to receive before they agree to having an agent represent them.

As for the federal promise of open bidding, Housing Minister Spokesperson Micaal Ahmed said that since real estate generally falls under provincial and territorial jurisdictions, the federal government continues to consult with stakeholders to make a home buyers’ bill of rights.

The work is well underway and nearing completion, he said.

 

Return to the Front page

Ontario has partnered with some Staples retail locations to make it easier to access government services

By Staff

December 10th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

Ontario has partnered with some Staples retail locations to make it easier to access government services

The Ontario government has partnered with some Staples retail locations that make it easier and more convenient for families and businesses to access vital government services such as driver’s licences and health cards.

Beginning in early 2024, Service Ontario is opening new centres in select Staples Canada stores with additional locations expected to open throughout the year.

Service Ontario location: 59 million transactions annually.

Examples of the new reach out in providing services:

The Township of Pickle Lake partnership provides a Service Ontario and municipal services hub for local residents as well as those travelling from communities further north.

For eligible residents who may find it difficult to visit Service Ontario to renew their health card, a live virtual appointment offers the same level of service as the in-person experience, right from the comfort of home.

To help meet increasing demand, eight of the busiest Service Ontario centres in the Greater Toronto Area now offer health card services for work permit holders and their accompanying family.

In partnership with Service Ontario, North Shore Tribal Council reaches several communities in the Robinson-Huron Treaty area with its mobile service unit, in addition to the Service Ontario centre operating in Cutler.

Service Ontario completes 59 million transactions annually, connecting people, families, and businesses with government services in person, online and by phone.

Return to the Front page

Burlington Muslim Youth Partner with Canadian Blood Services

By Staff

December 10th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

Members of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Youth Association donated 15 units of blood in Burlington to support Canadians in critical need.

Several Muslim youth from across Burlington and the Halton Region attended the blood drive which took place at the Canadian Blood Services at 1250 Brant St. These types of initiatives by the Ahmadiyya Muslim Youth Association are part of an ongoing effort to serve Canadians and demonstrate the true spirit of Islam.

Part of the group of Muslim men who took part in a national drive by the Muslim community.

Continuing its long-standing partnership with the Canadian Blood Services, the Ahmadiyya Muslim Youth Association is undertaking a nationwide initiative to donate blood. In collaboration with the Canadian Blood Services, hundreds of Muslim youth will be attending blood drives in various locations across Canada.

Blood drive held by the Ahmadiyya Muslim Youth Association as part of nationwide initiative

Return to the Front page

City asking for Expressions of Interest for 'refreshing' the area surrounding City Hall

By Pepper Parr

December 8th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

They are serious.

The city has put out Requests for Expressions of Interest for the renewal of Civic Square.

Public Art Plan (Phase 1) Civic Square Renewal. The City invites Canadian professional artists and artist-led teams to submit credentials and expressions of interest to create a Public Art Plan for the Civic Square

The City of Burlington will be refreshing the area surrounding City Hall. This includes Civic Square, City Hall’s Brant Street entrance and facade and the streetscapes of Brant Street and Elgin Street in the immediate area.

City wants to “refresh” the look of Civic Square and add a nicer entrance to City Hall. The work is covered by finds from the federal and provincial governments and more than $1 million that is currently sitting in a reserve account. No “impact” on the taxpayers.

The selected artist(s) will work directly with the City’s design and architecture teams to develop a Public Art Plan for integrated, permanent public artwork(s) to be installed in Civic Square.  Click HERE to learn more and access the online application.

Deadline:  Friday, February 2, 2024

Phase 1 Budget:    $20,000

Phase 2 Budget:    $150,000

Application Package:  Civic Square Application Package (PDF)

The assignment is to refresh the area surrounding City Hall. This includes Civic Square, City Hall’s Brant Street entrance and facade and the streetscapes of Brant Street and Elgin Street in the immediate area.

Scope of Work:  Phase 1 (Public Art Plan)

The selected artist(s) will work directly with the City’s design and architecture teams to develop a Public Art Plan for integrated, permanent public artwork(s) to be installed in Civic Square.

Key Deliverables (Phase 1)

Key deliverables include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • Attend approximately 8-10 project meetings (scheduled between May –December 2024).
  • Review background materials, public consultation results and preferred Civic Square design concept drawings and reports.
  • Prepare a draft Public Art Plan outlining options for public art and conceptual approach to the project. Present the draft plan to the Civic Square team for feedback.  Revise draft based on provided feedback.
  • Prepare and present a final Public Art Plan with finalized design details including artwork design renderings, materials list, timeline, budget, proposed subcontractors (if applicable), etc. The artist is not expected to provide engineer/shop drawings at this stage.
  • Provide ongoing project documentation and reports as required.
  • Meet with Civic Square design team for review and approval of final design concept(s).
  • The artist is not expected to supply any fabrication or installation services during Phase 1 of the project. A separate contract will be issued for Phase 2 (Artwork Fabrication and Installation).

Please note, Phase 1 of this project is for a Public Art Plan (preliminary design concept) only and does not include the engineering, fabrication, or installation of the artwork.  The selected artist will prepare a Public Art Plan that identifies opportunities for integrated public art projects.  This could include stand-alone artwork, functional artwork (i.e., seating, shade structures, etc.), surface treatments, etc. as well as helping to identify additional opportunities for temporary artwork and/or placemaking initiatives.  Once the Public Art Plan has been approved, the artist will be expected to provide preliminary renderings of the approved public art project(s) and integrations.

The selected artist will be issued a separate contract for Phase 2 of the project (Artwork Fabrication and Installation).  The approximate public art budget for Phase 2 is $150,000 (excluding below-grade foundations).  Budget allocations will be determined according to the scope of work that is approved in Phase 1.  It is anticipated that the artwork will be unveiled in the Summer/Fall of 2026.

How to Apply

Important!  Please download the full Civic Square Application Package (PDF) as this contains important project information and application instructions.  Applications may be submitted online via submittable.  You will need to create a free account to access the online application form.

Return to the Front page

Figuring out who gets to use Spencer Smith Park

By Pepper Parr

December 8th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

When the city decided that the Food Truck Festival wasn’t going to be allowed to host their event in Spencer Smith Park there was a hole in the schedule of events.

Who would use the space? – Whoever it is they would have to keep the BDBA happy.  That organization managed to ensure that the hospitality sector was given every opportunity to re-build and recover from the Covid19 damage.

A great park that is well managed. Determining the direction for the future is now before Council.

The issue before Council was to approve:

Direct the Director of Recreation, Community and Culture to pause the allocation of additional events at Spencer Smith Park until the comprehensive development of a Festivals and Events Policy in 2024.

Every year, the Festivals & Events office receives numerous requests from organizers wanting to host new events in Spencer Smith Park (SSP). Due to recent discussions at the Council regarding events held downtown, there is currently no established policy to prioritize one event over another. For the upcoming 2024 event season, there are several requests for new events, and some existing events are also looking for space in Spencer Smith Park (SSP) to benefit from the amenities offered by this premium park space.

The current process for event approval relies on historical use of the space and the event organizer’s compliance with the Special Event Team (SET) annual review.

Sandra Maxwell – Manager, Festivals & Events

Approval is granted under Delegated Authority by the Manager of Festivals & Events, assuming the event continues without significant changes. However, new events with an attendance of over 1,000 or significant changes to existing events trigger a community consultation process. This process informs residents and stakeholders about expected impacts and provides them with the opportunity to voice concerns. These concerns are addressed in advance, in consultation with the local Ward Councillor.

Park recovery time is also considered when reviewing booking requests in SSP. Major festivals are not scheduled back-to-back to allow Roads, Parks & Forestry (RPF) staff to perform necessary maintenance or repair damage. Smaller, less invasive events, such as walks and runs, are scheduled between larger ones as they have minimal impact on the grounds and don’t require added time for park recovery.

In most years, this approval system means that no new events can be accommodated in SSP during the spring/summer season because the park is fully booked with existing events.

Food Truck Festival drew good crowds – offering food and beverages that were comfortably priced. Burlington Restaurant Association felt the Food Trucks were taking business away from the brick and mortar operations.

However, due to the removal of Burlington’s Food Truck Festival and the former Children’s Festival event delivered by the City, there are potentially two open weekends; the weekend of July 20th (Food Truck) and the weekend of August 17th (Children’s Festival) that could be considered. Criteria for allocating space in the future will be developed through a new Festivals and Events policy for Council’s endorsement planned for 2024.

In the meanwhile, we are presenting the new event applications received for 2024 to Council for their awareness.

The event applicants seeking space in SSP for 2024 are as follows:

Council has dedicated significant time to deliberating on events and expressing the goal of distributing them across the city. Spencer Smith Park (SSP) consistently stands out as the most coveted location for event organizers, thanks to its prime location and amenities, including hydro, water, parking, and, of course, its expansive open space.

Furthermore, through these discussions, Council has pinpointed specific criteria that are considered vital for the city, such as promoting multiculturalism and inclusivity.

The following options may be considered by Council:

Council may choose to support any of the new events from the 2024 listed applicants in this report, and prioritize decision-making based on community needs. Approval can be granted for the event to commence in 2024, with an understanding that the event will likely seek continuation in subsequent years.

Alternatively, Council may choose to pause the introduction of any new events in SSP until specific criteria and a policy are developed to guide future decision-making processes in 2024. This approach allows for a more strategic and informed allocation of space in the park.

Event organizers are financially responsible for events held on public property. This includes covering all costs associated with running the event, as well as any expenses related to the use of City resources that support their event.

Events held in Spencer Smith Park (SSP) usually generate a lasting positive effect on businesses in the downtown core. Visitors often explore the downtown area and nearby establishments, contributing tourism dollars to the region. Additionally, many events incorporate local fundraising initiatives that directly benefit the community. It’s worth noting that the City charges a rental fee for the space used in SSP, covering both set-up and tear-down days before and after each event, as applicable.

RibFest fills the Park

Events taking place in Spencer Smith Park (SSP) necessitate varying levels of support from the Roads, Parks & Forestry (RPF) staff, contingent on their size and scale. This support is determined through a work order initiated by the Parks Supervisor and might involve staff working overtime or additional personnel to assist with major festivals.

Additionally, substantial staff time and resources are allocated to restore park grounds after hosting a major festival.

The introduction of new events affects members of the City’s Special Events Team (SET), who are responsible for scrutinizing all elements, approving site plans, and considering every aspect of a new event. This process demands a considerable amount of time compared to existing events with a proven track record in hosting events in Burlington, as they already comply with established requirements and expectations.

Staff connected with new event applicants to help determine suitability of the space request and gauge whether another location in Burlington might be considered by the applicant if they potentially were not successful in securing space in SSP in 2024. The result of this consultation is outlined in each event’s description under the Background & Discussion section within this report.

The substantial demand from external event organizers wanting to host events in Spencer Smith Park has led to a supply and demand challenge. Historically, the park has been fully booked during the bustling summer season, leading to the rejection of new event requests. For the upcoming year, our team will concentrate on crafting a Festivals and Events policy, aiming to establish clear criteria for the approval and support of events in Burlington, outlining specific parameters related to their timing, location, and nature. Until such criteria are established, staff believe it is prudent to refrain from introducing new events to this venue, as detailed in this report.

Related news story:

Spencer Smith Park Schedule

 

 

 

Return to the Front page

Large Stormwater Storage Tanks to be owned by 98 unit condo corp development on Millcroft golf course property has potential legal problems

By Staff

December 8th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

Daintry Klein was delegating on the Drainage By-law Amendment; one of those dry as toast subjects – until she revealed that the large stormwater storage tanks that are proposed to be privately owned by the new condo corporation.  At that point the delegation became more about what could happen to the current Millbrook residents and not so much about the bylaw amendment,

Mayor, Council, Staff and Fellow Burlingtonians,

“We would like to thank the Engineering Department for its work in updating this drainage by-law.  It acknowledges climate change and provides important updates to recognize the impacts of rainfall and groundwater in the potential for flooding.  The report also refers to best practices.  It seems that further work needs to be done and we look forward to the City, the Region, Conservation Halton and the Province to continue to address the rapidly evolving risks of Climate Change consistent with the work being done by the Federal Government and the insurance companies.  Through their extensive work, they have recommended their own set of best practices.

Yellow location are where developer Millcroft Greens want to build 98 homes.

“As homeowners, we rely on our governments to keep us safe.  To protect us from what many of us are unaware of in our daily lives as we go about our careers where our expertise is in other disciplines. As part of the planning and building process, grading and drainage is considered and clearance certificates are issued upon completion to ensure that properties are safe.

Alliance is one of two community groups opposed to the development of additional homes on golf course property.

“It has come to the attention of Millcroft Greenspace Alliance that other standards used by the City and Conservation Halton to evaluate the causes and risks of flooding also need updating.  We were initially encouraged to know that Conservation Halton, an organization that “Protects the Natural Environment from the Escarpment to Lake Ontario” is engaged in the East Burlington Creeks Flood mapping study.  As we read the most recent report, we learned that the analysis is not relied upon by insurance companies.  This raised questions for us.  Further investigation led us to learn that Public Safety Canada and the insurance companies rely on the same flood modelling as FEMA in the United States which is a newer, more complex computer program that includes the impacts of rainfall.

“A National flood insurance plan would be based on this type of modelling.   Conservation Halton and the City use HEC-RAS, a 1D model that considers surface water with adjustments but doesn’t include rainfall.  When we have made inquiries to Conservation Halton, they advise us that they only consider riverine flooding.  So, as we understand it, after the creeks and natural drainage are altered and channelized and the new regulation limits are established, Conservation Halton no longer considers the impacts of the broader watershed in its development decisions.

Klein: “The proposed update of this drainage by-law could be of particular interest to the homeowners in Millcroft.

“The proposed update of this drainage by-law could be of particular interest to the homeowners in Millcroft. We are aware of the experience of infill development particularly in south Burlington.

“Argo Development Corp and Millcroft Greens have to-date refused to withdraw their proposed development application. The City and the Region have unanimously opposed and subsequently requested, that the Province step in and issue an MZO.”

It was at this point that Committee Chair Rory Nisan cut in and asked Ms Klein to stick to the subject which was the Drainage By-law Amendment.  Klein explained that she was trying to put her delegation into context and what it would mean in practical terms to Millbrook residents; Klein continued. This wasn’t the last time Chair Nisan cut in.

“The City on September 26 and the Region of Halton on October 18 of this year for reference of the passage of time.  We are still waiting for the Province to act. Although the Premier is on record saying that he will not allow building on floodplains, he still has not stopped this development application. Hundreds of emails have been sent.

“At issue, is the fact that the Millcroft Golf Course greenspace was designed to drain the adjacent properties and slow the flow of drainage from the Escarpment to Lake Ontario, protecting properties to the south.  As of December 1st, the witness statements for their OLT appeal are in.  Glen Wellings, the planner on the Millcroft Greens file, diligently details the process and dates of the application but forgets to mention the stormwater peer review or the Conservation Halton flood mapping.  He refers to the 6th and 7th holes as gently rolling with some flat areas.

The mill pond is a critical part of the infrastructure that has managed stormwater.

“As Millcroft homeowners, we understand from the initial engineering reports that the topography is actually contoured berms and swales that direct water through the fairway open channels toward the stormwater catch basins that take the water through the stormwater easements to the Millpond. And the fact that our properties were designed to have the functional drains 2.5 meters above the bottom of the fairways is also very relevant.  This is all documented in the original documents when the Millcroft subdivision was created.

“The developer is proposing to fill the fairways up with topsoil and reduce the grade to the 2% guidelines.  This could disperse the water across the neighbourhood into the existing homeowner properties causing the type of flooding that this drainage by-law seeks to address.

“The large stormwater storage tanks that are proposed to be privately owned by the new condo corporation are designed to manage the ongoing stormwater flows for our neighbourhood.  These will be maintained by our neighbours and we must look to them financially for failure? They are also detailing that the new homes will be equipped with sump pumps – something the existing homes were not designed for due to the existence of the grading to the bottom of the fairways from our rear lot lines.  Not to mention the fact that the proposed new rear yards will have catch basins in their back yards that manage the stormwater for the neighbours – potentially the site of a pool or patio in the future or garden refuse.  Topics this by-law seeks to address. And we note that the engineers of this proposed application accept no liability for their work? Relying on legal recourse against neighbours to protect our properties is contrary to the goal of community building.

Klein: “We are not clear on the process to recover potential losses from the after effects of the proposed construction if it isn’t stopped by the Province. 

“We are not clear on the process to recover potential losses from the after effects of the proposed construction if it isn’t stopped by the Province.  The by-law suggests that ultimately, the Property Owners will be liable.  However, if allowed, Argo and Millcroft Greens will change the existing Millpond, watercourses, ditches and swales and other existing green infrastructure per their development plans. The unsuspecting new homeowners of the proposed condominium corporations could be left with the liability long after Argo has withdrawn all funds from the development corporation. Would it be reasonable for builders to share in the financial responsibility for potential impacts of their actions? Should they be required to own and fund the proposed infrastructure?

“Recognizing that the Millcroft golf course greenspace is actually a natural form of the City’s stormwater management system, we urge the City to take all necessary steps to ensure that Millcroft Greens is prevented from building homes on this land.  Public Safety Canada in its report of August 2022 prescribes best practices to include natural infrastructure as method of mitigating flood risks.  As taxpayers, we ask the City to mitigate our collective risk and protect this greenspace.”

Klein is of the view that she was interrupted by the chair because some of what we had to say may be uncomfortable.

“This City endured the 2014 flood with many residents incurring out of pocket expenses to repair damages.  We believe many residents are unaware of the potential flooding impacts of proposed infill development. The Province does set guidelines on stormwater however they seem to be outdated relative to Public Safety Canada and the insurance companies.  There may be options for the City to implement its own guidelines.

Klein: Should the unsuspecting homeowners take on the liability?

“Our comments highlight information from the East Burlington Creeks study and notes from the City which we believe could result in unintended consequences for homeowners in the future after homes are built and the developer is gone. Should the unsuspecting homeowners take on the liability?

“The City has the opportunity to solve the issue of the proposed development on the Golf Course greenspace.  It is part of the stormwater infrastructure for the City and we are unaware of any other infrastructure of the City that is privately owned and controlled.  After three years of study, we look forward to this coming to a positive ending for the community as a whole before the OLT.”

What Klein chose to be polite about and not mention the grandstanding the Mayor did at a community meeting a number of months ago saying she was working with the then Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing about the issuing of a Ministerial Zoning Order (MZO) that would end the matter before it got to the Ontario Land Tribunal.

Relayed new stories

Greenspace Alliance purpose

High end homes planned for Millcroft community

Return to the Front page

What takes place when at Spencer Smith Park

By Staff

December 8th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

What takes place in Spencer Smith Park ?  Who decides what takes place?

Spencer Smith Park seen from the west. The circle in the forefront was the location of the famous Brant Inn.

The calendar of events:

RibFest: The length of the line-up told which ribs were most popular.

Sound of Music. The place is packed for the biggest free concert event in the country.

 

Return to the Front page

'The Evolution of Sports Gambling in Canada: A Historical Perspective'

By Trevor Hurry

December 7th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

Sports gambling has been a contentious topic in Canada for many years, with its roots reaching back to the country’s early history. This article aims to explore the evolution of sports gambling in Canada, tracing its path from a frowned-upon activity to a widely accepted form of entertainment and a significant contributor to the economy.

Early Beginnings

Slahal: More than just a recreational activity – it was a social event and a means of acquiring wealth, and it held deep cultural significance.

The earliest known instance of gambling in Canada can be traced back to its indigenous tribes, who played a game of chance called Slahal. This game was more than just a recreational activity – it was a social event and a means of acquiring wealth, and it held deep cultural significance. However, with the arrival of the French and English colonizers, all forms of gambling, except for horse racing, were harshly restricted.

This restriction persisted for 77 years, with illegal gambling rings providing the only avenue for those wanting to try their luck. It wasn’t until 1969 that the Canadian government sanctioned provincial lotteries, with the caveat that the proceeds had to be given to charity. Recognizing the lucrative nature of gambling, the government eventually began amending the Criminal Code to permit more forms of gambling activities.

Legal Reform and Expansion

Throughout the 1970s and 80s, the Canadian government embarked on a series of legal reforms to expand the scope of sanctioned gambling activities. In 1985, an amendment to the Criminal Code transferred the control over gambling to individual provinces, allowing them to operate and license gambling establishments. This was a key step forward in the growth of sports gambling in Canada, as it enabled the establishment of province-run sports lotteries like Proline and Mise-O-Jeux.

However, these early attempts at regulated sports gambling were not without their limitations. The province-run systems were restrictive, allowing for only parlay bets within a lottery ticket format. This meant that to win, players had to accurately predict the outcome of at least three separate games. Additionally, the regulations varied greatly between provinces, adding another layer of complexity for players. Despite these challenges, Canadians were enthusiastic about the ability to legally place bets on sports events, marking a turning point in the acceptance of sports gambling in the country.

Transition to Online Gambling

As the digital age advanced, so did the world of sports gambling. The 1990s marked the emergence of online casinos, creating a new sphere for gambling enthusiasts. Initially, the legality of these platforms operated in a gray area. However, as their popularity soared, the government could no longer ignore the burgeoning online gaming sector. The Kahnawake Gaming Commission, established in 1996, was one of the first jurisdictions worldwide to realize the opportunities presented by the digital age, granting licenses to online gambling sites.

As Internet connectivity and technology evolved, the online gambling industry experienced exponential growth throughout the 2000s. The convenience and accessibility of online gambling platforms appealed to a broader audience, and the introduction of live betting added another dimension to sports gambling. Despite the availability of offshore online sportsbooks, the Criminal Code did not sanction single-event betting, which led to the loss of potential revenue for the Canadian government. This scenario paved the way for the push toward the legalization of single-game sports betting, culminating in the passing of Bill C-218 in 2021.

Current State of Sports Gambling in Canada

As of today, the sports gambling scene in Canada has undergone a transformational change. The passing of Bill C-218 in 2021 marked a significant milestone, as it legalized single-event sports betting, a much-awaited move that has opened up new avenues for both bettors and operators. This development is expected to bring significant taxable revenue, further supporting community needs, hospitals, and schools.

Ontario, being the most densely populated province, has taken the lead by welcoming commercial operators, clearing $1 million within the first week of legalization. Despite the slow roll-out of commercial operations, scheduled to fully come into effect by March 2022, the excitement within the industry is palpable. Key industry players, keen to capitalize on this upswing, are setting their sights on Ontario as their next venture.

In this vibrant and dynamic market, platforms such as FanDuel Canada stand out, offering sophisticated content, publishing capabilities, and multiple live sports and betting odds feeds to engage players before, during, and after the games. Indeed, the current state of sports gambling in Canada represents a remarkable evolution from its early beginnings, and it continues to carve out its path into the future.

Return to the Front page

City conducting public test of Alert Burlington on December 14, 2023

By Staff

December 7th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

A test of Alert Burlington, Burlington’s public notification system for community emergencies will take place on Thursday, December 14, 2023 at 11:45 a.m.

Subscribers will receive a test notification through the communication methods they have selected. This could be any combination of email, text or phone (voice).

The message will identify that it is a test and no action is required. Subscribers will not be asked to provide any personal information.

Unlike Alert Ready, Canada’s national public alerting system, Alert Burlington does not prompt an alert sound. Notification sounds and pop-ups are based on each devices alert settings.

The purpose of testing the Alert Burlington system is to:

  • Increase awareness of the Alert Burlington system.
  • Remind subscribers to check their account to ensure all information is up-to-date.
  • Confirm the effectiveness and reliability of the alert system to ensure it operates as intended for administrators and users.
  • Remind residents to create and maintain an emergency plan.

Alert Burlington is Burlington’s public notification system for community emergencies. The purpose of Alert Burlington is to keep you informed about local emergencies like floods, gas leaks, and accidents that could put you or your property at risk.

In case of an emergency, Alert Burlington will send you important messages through text, email and/or phone calls on whether individuals in the affected area(s) need to evacuate or shelter-in-place.

Since its launch in 2022, there hasn’t been a need to send out any emergency alerts. However, it’s always a good idea to be prepared. Sign up for this free community alert service by visiting www.burlington.ca/alertburlington. You’ll need to provide your name, address, and contact information.

Robyn Heibert, Community Emergency Management Specialist:  “Annual testing of our local alert system is an important practice that ensures we’re prepared to communicate in a moments notice. We appreciate the cooperation of all of our Alert Burlington subscribers. For those who haven’t signed up for the platform yet, I encourage you to do so. It’s easy to sign up and will ensure that you receive timely instructions on what to do during large-scale emergencies or disasters.”

For information about Alert Burlington, or to subscribe to the free emergency alert service, visit www.burlington.ca/alertburlington

 

Return to the Front page

Alinea works at getting what it has wanted for some time - Employment Lands concerted to Multi Use- think residential

By Pepper Parr

December 7th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

The land-use planning scandal that has rocked Ontario’s Progressive Conservative government has revealed how the province utilized all manner of regulatory tools to force more housing on cities and towns – removing land from the protected area known as the Greenbelt, expanding urban boundaries and issuing special decrees known as minister’s zoning orders.

But a Globe and Mail analysis has uncovered a fourth, less discussed mechanism: re-writng municipal Official Plans.

The Ford government imposed two dozen policy changes on the city of Hamilton and the regions of Halton, Peel and York by rewriting their official plans – documents that guide what gets built and where. It altered local planning decisions by, among other things, making lands zoned for commercial use available for housing and foisting greater height limits on residential buildings, documents show.

Steve Clark, then the province’s housing minister, oversaw last year’s revisions of the official plans, including the policy changes.

As Minister of Municipal Affairs he signed off on ROPA 49, a document that has been very kind to Burlington FIX THIS He has since resigned, and his successor, Paul Calandra, has pledged to reverse the revisions. He asked mayors in October to tell him by Thursday what changes they want to keep.

Mayor Marianne Meed Ward

Mayor Meed Ward will meet that deadline with the letter she is sending the Minister was recommended at a Standing Committee earlier this week.

Alexandru Cioban, a spokesman for Mr. Calandra, said municipalities are in the best position to understand the “unique needs and concerns of their communities.”

The documents the Globe and Mail dug out shed light on how directives from political staff converted just under 200 hectares of employment lands – areas set aside for commercial or industrial purposes – to residential use and rezoned small parcels to increase density and height limits.

Mr. Amato also met in October, 2022, with Lobbyist Nico FidaniDiker, a former aide to Premier DougFord, regarding another policy change to an official plan.

Sandwiched in between the GO line on the left and Hwy 403 on the right the property is probably the most valuable pice of land in th city. Zoned as Employment lands that was changed in Regional Official Plan Amendment (ROPA) 49.

Mr. Amato discussed “three or four properties in the Halton area” on behalf of Mr. Fidani-Diker’s client Penta Properties, now known as Alinea Group Holdings, the Integrity Commissioner’s report says.

Penta was seeking approvals to build housing on three of its properties in Burlington, including a 71.5-hectare swath of lands that the regional government had designated for employment and commercial purposes. Planning staff in Halton Region opposed the requests, citing concerns that reducing the supply of employment lands could jeopardize the city’s job-creation targets, according to the internal government records.

Mr. Clark’s office gave Penta the green light. Burlington councillors unanimously voted in November to retain the province’s changes.

The new Minister of Municipal Affairs wanted to give the Clark decision a second thought and asked foe their views.

Burlington Mayor Marianne Meed Ward said in an interview that she supports the province’s move to bypass the regional council .“If you look at the kind of communities we foresee for the future, it is about mixed use ,” she said. “It’s about being able to come out the door of your house or your condo and walk to a community centre, to a park, to retail and to have jobs close by.”

This wasn’t a position held two years ago but times change.

Mayor Meed Ward is in the process of letting the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing know that she supports the decision.  Her letter is appended below.

Dear Minister Calandra,

Thank you for the opportunity to provide input on Regional Official Plan Amendment 49. When these modifications were first announced, Burlington City Council unanimously endorsed them.

Our position remains the same, and council unanimously endorsed this letter at our committee meeting of Dec. 5. Specifically, Burlington City Council unanimously supports the following:

      • Maintaining the 2051 time horizon. The Burlington Official Plan, 2020, Targeted Realignment Exercise – Initial Work Plan and associated efforts will include technical study, planning analysis and engagement to clarify local growth Population and employment expectations are likely to be significantly higher than reflected in policy in Table 1 of the Halton Region Official Plan, as modified by the Minister.
      • Maintaining the addition of two new Urban Areas, specifically Eagle Heights and Bridgeview. The policies of the Regional Official Plan provide sufficient guidance to undertake appropriate processes to confirm the nature of development in these two
      • Maintaining the removal of the Employment Area overlay for Bronte Creek Meadows and 1200 King Road. Both areas are within the ROPA 38 Urban Boundary and may present key opportunities to explore and potentially leverage servicing priority through discussions with the Region of Halton.

The City of Burlington remains committed to meeting or exceeding our Housing Pledge of 29000 units, which council unanimously endorsed earlier this year. As noted in the City’s Housing Pledge, while there is sufficient land within our pre-ROPA 49 urban boundary to accommodate 29,000 housing units by 2031, the lands affected by the Minister’s changes to the Region’s urban structure provide near and longer term opportunities for the City to deliver on a number of Provincial, Regional and City objectives.

The City of Burlington will continue to work collaboratively with the respective ROPA 49 landowners and the public in advancing the City’s interests on these lands. Priority will be given to achieving the City’s community responsive growth management objectives and long-term community development goals related to achieving vibrant mixed-use neighbourhoods inclusive of the following elements as outlined in our May 25, 2023 letter:

          • economic benefits including future employment targets that increase future property assessment growth.
          • social benefits including affordable and attainable housing, public parks and greenspace and community facilities and amenities.
          • environmental benefits including climate mitigation and adaption, natural heritage preservation and enhanced integrated mobility.

Everyone deserves a safe and affordable place to call home. We look forward to working together with the Province of Ontario, the public, and the development community on innovative solutions and partnerships to increase attainable housing options for residents at every stage of life.

Sincerely,

Mayor Marianne Meed Ward City of Burlington

Related news story:

 

Return to the Front page

Current City Manager Tim Commisso Started in the Finance Department When He First Began Working for the City

By Pepper Parr

December 7th,2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

During the budget debates City Manager Tim Commisso said on more than one occasion that Burlington had zero tax increases for a number of years, making the point that during those zero tax years there wasn’t enough money being applied to the upkeep of the infrastructure.

Councillor Paul Sharman frequently talks about the several million dollar infrastructure deficit. That deficit is so high that they city had to put a special tax levy in place that was dedicated to infrastructure upkeep.

We find it interesting that Commisso would blame a previous Mayor for not collecting enough in the way of taxes while working in the Finance department – where he would have known just what the problems were.

The size of the infrastructure deficit? It started growing during City Manager Tim Commisso was working in finance.

Would he not have advised the Mayor at the time that more money had to be allocated to infrastructure upkeep?

Our source has Tim Commisso starting out in the Finance Dept. “ I assume he was hired by Bob Carrington but I can’t remember when he started.  In the early 2000s after the retirement of Gary Goodman and the departure of Ed Sajecki to Mississauga.

“Commisso was successful in becoming one of three General Managers under Tim Dobbie (the other two being Bob Carrington and Leo DeLoyde).

“Tim’s General Manager responsibilities involved the Development Division (Planning, Engineering and Building).  Given his involvement in finance, this involved a steep learning curve which he was able to surmount in good time.”

Perhaps the culture in the municipal sector is – you don’t speak up.

A reader sent us the following information on the amount of time Tim Commisso spent with the city before he moved to Thunder Bay:

City of Burlington
15 yrs 8 mos
General Manager
Oct 1999 – Sep 2008 · 9 yrs

Deputy Treasurer
Feb 1993 – Oct 1999 · 6 yrs 9 mos

Return to the Front page

A Little Poem that is Hard to Look At: 'We draw in our dreams, in our imaginations'

By Pepper Parr

December 6th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

We hear the news day in, day out.

How do we react to stuff like this?

Yesterday: A school where civilians were sheltering was bombed as Israel expanded its offensive in Khan Younis, the south’s largest city.

In Israel: Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had a contentious meeting with families of hostages still held by Hamas, who accused him of not doing enough to return them.

We see the pictures of bodies wrapped in white cloth dozens of them. Our part of the world doesn’t have experiences like this; how do we react?

Gazans laying out the bodies readying for burial; a daily exercise that has seen more than 14,000 Gazans killed as the Israel Defence Force hunts the Hamas leadership.

Many in Canada protest strongly for the Palestinian community demanding that their rights be recognized while almost is as many demonstrate for the Israeli’s who believe they have a right to be in Gaza to totally destroy Hamas, the political group that has been running the form of government that exists in Gaza and the terrorist group that sent men into Israel and murdered at least 1400 Israelis and took more than 200 prisoners, many of them still in the hands of Hamas who are trading them for Hamas fighters who are being held in Israeli prisons.

A Canadian, currently working at a university in the UK, has worked in Palestine for a number of years.  Fluent in Arabic, she does a lot of translation from Arabic into English.

Set out below is some of her work:

 

Return to the Front page

RONA Celebrating converted locations in Burlington

By Pepper Parr

December 6th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

Whenever there is competition in any sector of the economy the consumers is the winner.

When Staples took over Office Depot it didn’t take long for Staples to forget about the needs and interests of the customers.

RONA will celebrate the Grand Opening of the newly converted locations in Burlington and Milton with “board cutting” ceremonies to mark the reopening of the new RONA+ stores. These events will present a unique photo opportunity with the store teams and members of RONA inc.’s leadership team, as well as participating elected officials.

U can see the photo op already – Mayor Meed Ward with hard hat and goggles running a Skill saw through a 2×4

The conversion of the former Lowe’s store to the brand-new RONA+ banner is part of a wider plan aimed at redefining how Canadians shop for home improvement and represents a significant local investment. Through this process, the company is looking to build on the strong legacy of the RONA brand and build momentum for this Canadian-operated household name.

There will be a new sign on the location by the time you get there.

While RONA took over Lowe’s – there are other strong competitors in this sector, 

From Thursday, December 7 to Monday, December 11, the RONA stores will offer the local community an array of special activities to celebrate the Grand Opening of the stores, including a big community event complete with kids’ workshops, food and entertainment on Saturday, December 9 and Sunday, December 10, from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.

RONA+ Burlington

What:             Board cutting ceremony of the new Burlington RONA+ store

When:            Thursday, December 7

10:30 a.m. – 11 a.m.

Who:              Paul Faulds, Store Manager, RONA+ Burlington

Marc Macdonald, Senior Vice President, Human Resources, RONA inc.

Ashutosh Rai, Community Engagement Manager, on behalf of MP Pam Damoff

Where:           3270 Harrison Crescent, Burlington

Grand Opening activities

  • Thursday, December 7, Friday, December 8 and Monday, December 11
  • Pro event in stores from 6 to 9 a.m.
    • Pro breakfast
    • Vendors in store to meet Pros
    • Free gifts for Pros (limited quantities)
  • Saturday, December 9 and Sunday, December 10

o   Family event in stores from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.

  • Free food
  • Kids’ workshop
  • Raffle
    • Free bucket (first 200 customers)
    • $25 gift card with the purchase of $100 or more.
Return to the Front page

So this is where things are with development in Burlington?

By Pepper Parr

December 6th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

Dave Amborski, a professor at the Centre for Urban Research at Toronto Metropolitan University, formerly Ryerson.

Dave Amborski, a professor at the Centre for Urban Research at Toronto Ryerson delivered a lecture on the home building industry and how development finance works and ties into municipal finance.  He has graduate degrees in both economics and planning.  He teaches planning at Toronto Metropolitan University (formerly Ryerson, this is his 50th year. He started the Center for Urban Research and Land development.

We will publish the complete lecture once the transcription is complete.

Today we want to share the questions that Councillor Sharman asked.  The answers may surprise you – they surprised us.

Sharman dropped this one on Amborski:

Ward 5 Councillor Paul Sharman puts questions to a Toronto Metropolitan University lecturer.

We have this little conundrum. Here in Burlington we’ve committed to build 29,000 units or have built 29,000 units by 2031. And we look at our official plan and what we see is that we’re going to have 82% of the of our development in the future to be high density 12% to be mid rise, mid density and 6% to be low density. And we live in a world defined by how interest rates and were built out. Do you have any suggestions on how we might accomplish 29,000 units in the next 10 years?

Amborski: Well, I haven’t looked very carefully at your official plan and your boundaries. That mix seems wrong to me; having too much high rise and not enough ground associated here. The data should tell us something about what some of the issues are. But it would seem that you would need more ground associated homes to meet the needs of your of your community if people want to live here because that seems to be what people are looking for.

Sharman later said to Dave Amborski:

We have 41,000 units presently in our planning pipeline. We know, we believe, that none of them or a lot of them cannot be built because of the need for pre-sales which at this point are just not there. This is the first time Sharman has said this publicly.

Sharman also asked:

And that other question is with respect to affordable housing, because one of my one of my colleagues online is terribly keen on this.  We can’t figure out how to get affordable housing here in the province in a city where land is extremely valuable. And there’s no upper level government support because it’s not happening anymore and given what I’ve already told you about, you know, the mix of mix of development that’s in the plans.

 

Return to the Front page

Ontario in Top Ten Ranking of Math Students. Report says 'student well-being and academic rigour often go together.'

By Pepper Parr

December 5th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

While Canadian teenagers score well on international math, reading and science tests — scores in all three subjects have declined over the past two decades, according to a new global ranking released Tuesday.

“While it is evident that some countries and economies are performing very well in education, the overall picture is more worrying,” wrote  Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, ( OECD) Director for Education and Skills Andreas Schleicher in a report about the PISA 2022 test, which focused on math.

“In more than two decades of global PISA tests, the OECD average score has not changed drastically between consecutive assessments. But this cycle saw an unprecedented drop in performance.”

OECD Director for Education and Skills Andreas Schleicher

In media interviews Schleicher said while COVID-19 played a role, the downward trend in some countries, including Canada, started before the pandemic. Factors include a general decline in perceived teacher support and the “extensive use of technology for leisure.”

This is the first large-scale study to collect data on student performance, well-being and equity since the pandemic-related disruptions resulted in school closures and the pivot to online learning. The tests also reveal how Canadian teens fared in each province. Ontarians performed above the national average in reading and science, but not math. Alberta was the only province to score above the national average in all three subjects.

Canada was above the OECD average in all subjects, ranking fourth in science and fifth in math and reading. When compared with all participants, Canada ranked in the top 10 in all subjects. Singapore was number one in all areas.

Ontario Education Minister Stephen Lecce, who is the chair of the Council of Ministers of Education, Canada, said “overall, it’s a very positive reflection” of what’s going on in classrooms across the country.

Ontario Education Minister Stephen Lecce.

Ontario, he added, is in the top 10 internationally, which shows the province’s back-to-basics strategy is working, along with investments in literacy and numeracy supports such as a math lead in every school board and early reading screening for primary schoolchildren starting in senior kindergarten.

“All of this, together, leads us to a better outcome,” Lecce said at Queen’s Park. “So it’s promising, but a recognition that we’ve got obviously more work to do to get these kids back on track.”

Although Canada ranked high, its scores have trended downward, as have other countries’ around the globe. Compared with 2012, the proportion of students here scoring below baseline proficiency (Level 2) increased by seven percentage points in math, seven percentage points in reading, and four percentage points in science.

“If you do not reverse that, it’s just going to continue,” warned Schleicher, pointing out that Finland took top spot in 2000 and everyone looked to it as a model education system. “Now, (Finland) is an average performer. They have been very complacent.”

Schleicher  added Canada could do better with “a curriculum that is more ambitious and has high expectations for students,” adding there has been a tendency in recent years to “sacrifice rigour” in order to please students. But he notes that “student well-being and academic rigour often go together.”

We have to just teach fewer things at greater depths,” he said. “In Canada, students often are good at the first layer of a problem, but they do not have the deep conceptual understanding” to get at the heart of a math problem.

Schleicher also recommended that teachers invest more time in their relationships with students so they feel supported. He was “surprised” that when kids switched to online learning due to school closures, just 13 per cent of Canadians reported being asked daily, by someone from the school, how they were feeling.

“That’s a striking number,” he said. “During the pandemic, caring for your students was perhaps even more important than giving them homework.”

Ontario students were out of class and learning online, about 27 weeks, which was more than many students around the world.

Return to the Front page

Bonnie Crombie in the Legislature by Easter?

By Pepper Parr

December 5th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

“If a seat presented itself that was logical, of course I would seek that seat,” Bonnie Crombie told  Newstalk 1010 radio.


It hasn’t been announced yet – but expect to see Bonnie Crombie sitting in the Legislature making life difficult for Premier Doug Ford.

Which means we can expect to see her in the Legislature in the not too distant future. Which of the nine Liberal MPPs will give up their seat for Crombie shouldn’t be that hard to figure out.  Crombie is also reported to have said: “a local Liberal candidate has been selected.”

The Premier has a period of time within which he has to meet with the Lieutenant Governor and arrange to have a by- election held.

The by election lasts 28 days.

Could she be in the provincial Legislature by Easter?

Return to the Front page

Thomson Outs Council on the Handling of the Consent Agenda

By Pepper Parr

December 4th, 2023

BURLINGTON, ON

 

Jim Thompson was back before a Standing Committee to first remind them that when there are delegations speaking to a matter it cannot be on the Consent agenda.

Items on the Consent agenda are matters that the Clerk’s Office do not feel require debate.  Any member of Council can pull an item from the Consent agenda and have it up for debate.

Jim Thomson, appearing before the Standing Committee virtually.

Thomson, took part in the meeting virtually – he hasn’t appeared in Council chambers since the meeting during which he was escorted out the door.

Okay, good morning. First, why is CL 22 Dash 23 still on the consent agenda? I am delegating on it. So it doesn’t meet the no delegations requirement of section 35.1 of the procedure bylaw.

Secondly, let me say that I approve of the way the changes to the notification policy are shown in the document. The old language is struck through and the new language is clearly shown in place. This should be the standard for all changes to bylaws. This is 1990s word processing technology that the clerk’s office should have adopted a long time before now.

Thirdly, with regards to changes necessary due to the loss of the Burlington Post. I don’t believe that Burlington is unique in no longer having print media.  I saw nothing in the report that referenced other communities made in Burlington is expensive if other communities have already solved the problem. With specific regards to the Hamilton Spectator how many subscribers does it have in Burlington? Does it reach enough of the population to make it worthwhile placing ads in it?

Fourthly, I find it hard to believe that there are no climate implications to this change. For starters, there are going to be fewer dead trees. Going out all electronic means consuming more electricity. If we move everything to electricity, we’re going to have to have more clean energy electrics, more clean energy electric sources. This means more hydro or nuclear to increase the base-load coverage that makes up for the times when the sun doesn’t shine and the wind doesn’t blow Lastly, I noted the engagement matters the public wasn’t consulted.

Personally, I get my media electronically, but there is a significant portion of the population that isn’t on the net and or preferred to get paper copies. With regards to the policy itself, does the municipal act allow waiving the public notice procedure other than for the urgent or emergency situations as defined in objective nine of the policy?

How is Council held accountable? How is the city manager held accountable? Was the city clerk held accountable?

To be clear, what are the consequences of failure of any of those names, that they do not meet the responsibilities under the policy or in fact violate the notification policy? Thank you for your time. Are there any questions or will they just be ignored as usual?

Committee Chair: Are there any questions for Jim Thompson? Seeing none, thank you for your delegation today Jim.

Return to the Front page